Quick answer

Choose the Photogenic Supply Co. 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky) if you want a single understated cap that nods to film history. Choose the PhotoLove Hat if you want to pick a color from a wider palette or prefer a soft cotton build with a contrasting underbill.

Color choice is the clearest divider

The 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky) comes in one color, so the decision is about the design rather than matching a wardrobe. The PhotoLove Hat is offered in Mint, Sky Blue, 18% Grey, Pink, Safelight Red, Purple Fringe, and Night Sky, which makes it easier to coordinate with a camera bag, jacket, or team outfit.

If you want a cap that stays quiet in photos and blends with most gear, Night Sky works in either style. If you want the hat itself to be a small piece of photo personality, the broader PhotoLove palette gives you more room to choose.

Adjustability and construction

The PhotoLove Hat is described as adjustable and made from 100% soft cotton, with a contrasting underbill. That combination suits everyday wear and travel, where comfort and a secure fit matter more than structured shape.

The catalog does not list closure type, crown height, or brim measurements for either hat. If you are between sizes or need a precise fit, check the product page for any additional sizing details before ordering, or choose the adjustable PhotoLove Hat when fit flexibility is your priority.

Price and value

At catalog prices, the 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky) is USD 23.68 and the PhotoLove Hat is USD 26.88. The gap is small, so let color choice and fit decide rather than the difference alone.

Both are listed with comparison prices, but availability and final pricing can change. Treat the catalog price as a starting point and confirm at checkout.

Decision rules for choosing your photo cap

  • If you want one understated cap: Pick the 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky) when you prefer a single dark color that works with most gear and outfits.
  • If color matching matters: Choose the PhotoLove Hat when you want to select from Mint, Sky Blue, 18% Grey, Pink, Safelight Red, Purple Fringe, or Night Sky.
  • If fit flexibility is a priority: Lean toward the adjustable PhotoLove Hat, especially if you are unsure of your head size or share the cap.
  • If you want a soft cotton feel: The Photo Love Hat (Monochrome) is described as 100% soft cotton with a contrasting underbill, making it a comfortable daily option.

Product facts

  • Photogenic Supply Co. 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky): The 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky) is a single-color dad hat tied to the 35mm film format. It suits buyers who want one understated photo-themed cap without choosing from a palette.

    Photogenic Supply Co. 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky)

    Photogenic Supply Co. 35mm Dad Hat (Night Sky)

  • Photogenic Supply Co. PhotoLove Hat: The PhotoLove Hat is available in seven colors, including Mint, 18% Grey, and Safelight Red. More color options make it easier to match a specific outfit or gear setup.

    Photogenic Supply Co. PhotoLove Hat

    Photogenic Supply Co. PhotoLove Hat

  • Photogenic Supply Co. Photo LoveHat (Monochrome): The Photo Love Hat (Monochrome) is made from 100% soft cotton and is adjustable, with a contrasting underbill. That build favors comfortable everyday wear and a fit you can adjust.

Who should choose which

Best for

  • Photographers who want a single dark, film-themed dad hat
  • Buyers who prefer an understated look that matches most camera gear
  • Shoppers looking for a lower catalog price

Not for

  • Buyers who want to choose from several colors
  • Shoppers who need an adjustable closure and soft cotton build