Why Compare These Two Picture Books?

Both A Costume for Charly and Alice in a Winter Wonderland are hardcover picture books that center around a holiday — Halloween and a winter wonderland setting — and both feature a main character on a quest for self-expression. But they serve very different readers and purposes. This comparison helps you decide which book (or both) fits your family, classroom, or gift list.

Key Facts at a Glance

  • Alice in a Winter Wonderland: A striking rendition of Alice in Wonderland transported to a shimmering Alaskan tundra, in Jan Brett's rich signature style. This is a classic story reimagined with a unique setting, appealing to fans of traditional fairy tales and nature-inspired art.

    Alice in a Winter Wonderland

    Alice in a Winter Wonderland

  • A Costume for Charly: Halloween has always been tricky for Charly, but this year they are determined to find a costume that represents their feminine and masculine identities equally. This book directly addresses gender identity and self-acceptance, offering representation and a conversation starter for families.

    A Costume for Charly

    A Costume for Charly

Holiday Focus and Setting

  • Alice in a Winter Wonderland: Set in an Alaskan glacier landscape, this story follows Alice as she chases a white rabbit down a crevasse into a world of absurd characters. It's a winter fantasy, not tied to a specific real holiday, but perfect for cozy seasonal reading.
  • A Costume for Charly: Centered on Halloween, the story builds toward trick-or-treating. The holiday provides a natural deadline that drives the plot and makes the costume decision urgent and relatable.

Themes and Reader Takeaway

  • Alice in a Winter Wonderland: Classic whimsy and adventure. Readers enjoy familiar characters (Cheshire Cat, Duchess, King and Queen) reimagined as Alaskan animals. The message is about curiosity and embracing the absurd.
  • A Costume for Charly: Identity and self-expression. Charly searches for a costume that honors both their feminine and masculine sides. The book delivers an affirming message about being yourself, especially relevant for gender-diverse children and their families.

Which One Should You Choose?

If you're looking for a whimsical, beautifully illustrated winter story that introduces young readers to a classic tale in a fresh setting, Alice in a Winter Wonderland is a strong choice. Its Alaskan animal characters and Jan Brett's signature art make it a standout for read-alouds.

For families seeking a book that validates gender identity and sparks conversations about self-expression, A Costume for Charly is a must-have. Its Halloween setting makes it timely and fun, but its message lasts all year.

Both books can complement each other: one for classic fantasy, one for modern inclusivity. Consider your child's interests and your family's values when deciding.