Quick answer

Choose Amigos Cigarillos if you want a classic, no-fuss box of 50 for social smoking or budget-friendly sessions. Pick Santa Fe Smooth Filtered if you prefer a mellow filtered smoke with a refined, light finish.

Filtered vs unfiltered: a key difference

Santa Fe Smooth Filtered cigarillos come with a filter, which softens the draw and reduces harshness. This makes them a good option if you are used to filtered cigarettes or want an extra-smooth experience. Amigos Cigarillos are unfiltered, giving you a more direct tobacco taste. Neither is better, but the filter changes the feel significantly.

Strength and flavor profile

Santa Fe Smooth is rated mild and delivers a refined, easy-going tobacco flavor. It is designed for smokers who want a lighter session without a strong nicotine hit. Amigos Original is also mild but offers a straightforward, classic cigarillo taste. If you value a smooth finish above all, Santa Fe stands out; if you want a no-nonsense traditional smoke, Amigos fits.

How to decide between Amigos and Santa Fe

  • If you want a filtered, mellow smoke: Go with Santa Fe Smooth Filtered. Its mild strength and smooth finish are ideal for short breaks when you want a light, refined experience.
  • If you need a bulk box for casual smoking: Choose Amigos Cigarillos. The box of 50 offers the lowest per-cigarillo cost, making it a practical choice for frequent or social smoking. Check the style options if you want variety within the box.
  • If you are unsure about strength: Both are mild, but Santa Fe is explicitly labeled mild and filtered, so it is the safer bet for nicotine-sensitive smokers. Amigos is also mild but unfiltered, so the hit may feel slightly stronger. Try a single pack of Santa Fe first if you are new to cigarillos.

Product facts at a glance

  • Santa Fe Smooth Filtered: Santa Fe Smooth Cigarillos are mild, made in Canada, and sized 3 7/8 x 20. The filter and small ring gauge make for a very light, quick smoke that is easy on the throat.

    Santa Fe Smooth Filtered

    Santa Fe Smooth Filtered

  • Amigos Cigarillos: Amigos Cigarillos come in a box of 50, are 4 x 26, and made by J. Cortez Cigars in Belgium. The larger box gives you more smokes for the price, and the slightly bigger ring gauge offers a bit more substance per cigarillo.

    Amigos Cigarillos

    Amigos Cigarillos

Which one fits you?

Best for

  • Smokers who want a filtered, ultra-smooth mild smoke for quick sessions
  • Budget-conscious buyers who want a large quantity of classic cigarillos

Not for

  • Smokers seeking a full-bodied or strong cigarillo experience
  • Those who prefer a flavored or infused cigarillo (both are unflavored)