Quick answer
Choose the BIBS Try-It Collection 3 pack if you want to test three nipple shapes before committing, or the BIBS Supreme 2 pack if your baby already prefers a flat, symmetrical nipple and you want a wide-shield option.
Nipple shape: variety vs a known preference
The Try-It pack includes three different nipple shapes in natural rubber latex: round, symmetrical and anatomical. That variety lets you observe which shape your baby accepts most comfortably, which is useful when you have no prior experience with dummies. The Supreme pack, by contrast, uses a single symmetrical flat drop-shaped nipple, so it suits a baby who has already shown a preference for that flatter profile. If you are still discovering what works, the Try-It pack gives you more information; if you already know, the Supreme pack avoids unused dummies.
Material and shield differences
The Try-It Collection is made from natural rubber latex, while the Supreme is available in both natural rubber latex and silicone. The Supreme also features an exclusive wide shield made from 100% safe food-grade material. A wider shield can be helpful for babies who tend to press a dummy deeply into the mouth, but it may feel bulkier on a very small face. Neither pack lists shield dimensions, so if shield size is a deciding factor, check the product page or contact the store before ordering.
Pack size and value
The Try-It pack contains three dummies, while the Supreme pack contains two. Both are listed as Size 1 for 0+ months. At the catalog prices shown, the Try-It pack offers more dummies per pack, but the Supreme pack may be the better buy if you already know your baby likes the flat symmetrical shape. Consider how many dummies you want to keep in rotation: three gives you spares for the nappy bag and nursery, while two may be enough if you plan to wash frequently.
Trade-offs to weigh before you buy
- Variety vs certainty: The Try-It pack gives you three nipple shapes to test; the Supreme pack gives you one shape in a two-pack. Pick Try-It if you are still learning your baby's preference, or Supreme if you already know they like a flat symmetrical nipple. If you have never used a dummy with this baby, start with the Try-It pack to identify a shape.
- Material choice: Try-It is natural rubber latex only. Supreme is available in latex or silicone. If you specifically want silicone, the Supreme is the only one of these two packs that offers it. Check the material option on the Supreme product page before ordering if silicone is your priority.
- Shield size: The Supreme has a wide shield; the Try-It shield size is not stated in the catalog. If your baby has a small face or you are unsure, the Try-It pack may be the lower-risk first purchase because it does not commit you to a wide shield. For a newborn or a baby who seems overwhelmed by larger dummies, try the Try-It pack first.
- Pack count and value: Try-It gives three dummies; Supreme gives two. At the listed catalog prices, Try-It is the lower cost per dummy. But if you end up using only one shape, the extra dummies in the Try-It pack may go unused. Count how many dummies you need in rotation before choosing pack size.
Product facts at a glance
-
BIBS Try-It Collection Pacifiers 3 pack (Size 1) - Baby Blue: Size 1 (0+ months) pack of three dummies with round, symmetrical and anatomical nipples in natural rubber latex. Lets you try three nipple shapes with one purchase, which is helpful if your baby has not yet settled on a favourite.
BIBS Try-It Collection Pacifiers 3 pack (Size 1) - Baby Blue
-
BIBS Supreme Pacifiers 2 Pack (Size 1) - Ivory/Sage: Size 1 (0+ months) pack of two with a symmetrical flat drop-shaped nipple and a wide shield made from food-grade material. A good fit if your baby already prefers a flat symmetrical nipple and you want the wider shield option.
BIBS Supreme Pacifiers 2 Pack (Size 1) - Ivory/Sage
Which pack fits your baby?
Choose this if
- You are buying dummies for a newborn or a baby who has not yet shown a nipple-shape preference — the Try-It pack lets you test three shapes.
- You want natural rubber latex and prefer to have three dummies in rotation from the start.
- You are unsure about shield size and want to avoid committing to a wide-shield design.
Avoid this if
- Your baby already prefers a flat symmetrical nipple and you want a two-pack with a wide shield — choose the Supreme pack instead.
- You specifically want a silicone dummy — only the Supreme pack offers that material option.
- You only need one or two dummies and do not want unused shapes — the Supreme two-pack may be more practical.
