Quick answer
Choose the Black MAX Reflective Dog Collar if you often walk after dark or near traffic; choose the City of Roses Dog Collar if you want a lighter, patterned everyday collar and mostly walk in daylight.
Visibility is the main split
The Black MAX Reflective Dog Collar is built around reflective visibility, while the City of Roses Dog Collar is a patterned design without stated reflective elements. That difference matters most at dawn, dusk, and night, when drivers see contrast and reflection before they see color or pattern.
If your walks happen mostly in daylight, the reflective advantage is less important, and the City of Roses pattern becomes a reasonable style choice. For a dog collar for night walks, though, the reflective option is the safer default.
Shared construction you can count on
Both collars share the same practical core: a waterproof, no-stink build with an upcycled anti-bacterial backing, a Latch-Lock metal buckle, and a leash attachment that doubles as a bottle opener. They are also both handmade in Portland, Oregon.
Because those features are equal, your decision comes down to visibility versus pattern, not durability or hardware. Neither collar lists reflective trim on the other, so do not assume the City of Roses offers the same low-light performance.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Visibility vs. pattern: The Black MAX Reflective gives you reflective performance for low-light safety; the City of Roses gives you a decorative look but no stated reflectivity. If any regular walk happens after sunset, start with the reflective collar.
- Style vs. safety priority: The City of Roses is the better fit if you want a patterned collar for daytime outings and do not need reflective function.
- Fit and sizing: Both collars are sold by title option, and the catalog does not list size ranges. Measure your dog’s neck and compare it to the available options before ordering. When between sizes, size up for comfort and check the return policy.
Product facts at a glance
-
Black MAX Reflective Dog Collar: Reflective design with a waterproof, no-stink upcycled backing. The reflective surface helps your dog stand out in headlights, and the waterproof backing suits rainy or wet walks.
Black MAX Reflective Dog Collar
-
City of Roses Dog Collar: City of Roses pattern on the same waterproof, no-stink build. You get the same easy-care construction in a decorative pattern, but without stated reflective visibility for low-light walks.
City of Roses Dog Collar
Which collar fits your routine?
Best for
- Dog owners who walk at night, dawn, or dusk and want reflective visibility
- Dogs who swim or get wet often, thanks to the waterproof, no-stink backing
Not for
- Owners who mainly want a decorative pattern for daytime walks
- Dogs whose neck size falls outside the available title options
