Two Sizes of a Legendary Formula

Boy Butter Original is a coconut oil-based lubricant that goes clear on contact and lasts as long as any silicone formula. It's available in an 8 oz jar and a 9 oz squeeze bottle. Both deliver the same ultra-slick, long-lasting barrier, but the size and packaging differences can affect your buying decision. Here's how they compare so you can pick the right one.

Product Facts at a Glance

  • Boy Butter Original Formula 8 oz: 8 oz size, coconut oil-based, homogenized creamy formula, edible, non-toxic, washable with water. The 8 oz is a classic option with a smooth, light feel that works for massage and all forms of pleasure.

    Boy Butter Original Formula 8 oz

    Boy Butter Original Formula 8 oz

  • Boy Butter Original Formula 9 oz: 9 oz size, oil-based cream with organic shea butter and vitamin E, starts thick then melts clear, waterproof, washes off with soap and warm water. The 9 oz offers a richer, whipped-cream texture and skin-conditioning ingredients, plus a squeeze bottle for easy dispensing.

    Boy Butter Original Formula 9 oz

    Boy Butter Original Formula 9 oz

Key Differences Between the 8 oz and 9 oz

  • Container Type: The 8 oz comes in a jar, while the 9 oz comes in a squeeze bottle. The squeeze bottle may be more convenient for one-handed use or travel.
  • Texture and Feel: The 8 oz is homogenized into a creamy lube that goes clear on contact. The 9 oz starts as a thick, whipped cream that melts into a clear, frictionless slip. Both provide lasting slickness, but the 9 oz offers a more decadent initial feel.
  • Additional Ingredients: The 9 oz includes organic shea butter and vitamin E, which may leave skin feeling softer and more hydrated. The 8 oz formula does not list these extras.
  • Value: The 8 oz has a catalog price of $19.50 (compare at $26.00). The 9 oz is $19.43 (compare at $29.00). The 9 oz gives you more product for a slightly lower price per ounce.

Which Size Should You Choose?

If you want a classic, no-frills oil-based lube that's edible and washes off with just water, the 8 oz jar is a solid choice. It's also great if you prefer a jar for scooping out product with fingers or a spatula.

If you want a richer, skin-conditioning experience with organic shea butter and vitamin E, plus the convenience of a squeeze bottle, the 9 oz is the better pick. Its waterproof formula also makes it ideal for shower or hot tub use.

Compatibility Note

Both products are not compatible with latex condoms but can be used with non-latex condoms. They are safe for silicone toys and are 100% plant-based. Always check your toy and condom materials before use.