Two medium roasts, two different personalities
If you're looking for a medium roast from Stone Street Coffee, both the Brooklyn Roast 2LB and Southern Pecan fit the bill, but they offer very different flavor experiences. Brooklyn Roast is a blend of light and dark beans that creates a smooth, well-balanced cup with a harmonious contrast. Southern Pecan, on the other hand, is a flavored coffee with soft notes of butter and nuts, made from three varieties of Colombian arabica beans. Your choice comes down to whether you want a versatile everyday blend or a seasonal flavored treat.
Flavor and roast profile at a glance
Both are medium roasts, but they serve different taste preferences. Here's how they compare on flavor.
- Brooklyn Roast 2LB: A blend of bright, light beans and syrupy dark beans, creating a smooth, well-balanced medium roast. Described as 'harmonious' and 'contradicting yet harmonious,' it's a crowd-pleaser that works with any brew method. Kosher certified.
- Southern Pecan: A flavored medium roast with well-rounded notes of smooth butter and nutty, sweet pecans. Made from three varieties of Colombian arabica beans, it's described as 'Southern hospitality in a cup.' Also Kosher certified.
What the bags confirm about each coffee
-
Brooklyn Roast 2LB: Brooklyn Roast is a blend of light and dark beans, smooth and well-balanced, available in whole bean or three grind levels (coarse for French press, medium for drip, fine for espresso). If you use multiple brew methods or want a coffee that works for both drip and espresso, this blend gives you flexibility without changing flavor profile.
Brooklyn Roast 2LB
-
Southern Pecan: Southern Pecan offers customization of bag size, grind level, and flavor strength (light/regular, medium, strong) to tailor the intensity of the nutty, buttery notes. If you love flavored coffee but want control over how pronounced the pecan taste is, this customization is a real advantage.
Southern Pecan
Grind options and brewing flexibility
Brooklyn Roast 2LB comes as whole beans or pre-ground for French press (coarse), drip (medium), or espresso (fine). That covers the most common home methods. Southern Pecan offers the same grind options plus a choice of flavor strength—light, medium, or strong—so you can adjust the intensity of the pecan notes to your taste. If you brew with a French press or espresso machine, both can accommodate you, but Southern Pecan gives you an extra dial for flavor intensity.
Which one fits your routine?
Choose Brooklyn Roast if you want a straightforward, versatile medium roast that works for any brewing method and appeals to a wide range of palates. It's a reliable everyday coffee that doesn't compete with added flavors. Choose Southern Pecan if you're in the mood for a flavored coffee with a warm, nutty profile and you appreciate being able to dial in the flavor strength. It's a seasonal option that adds a special touch to your morning routine without being overpowering.
What the records don't confirm
Neither product record includes specific tasting notes beyond the supplied descriptions, nor do they confirm the origin of the beans beyond what's stated (Colombian for Southern Pecan; unspecified for Brooklyn Roast). The absence of allergen or dietary suitability information means you should not assume either is free of common allergens or suitable for specific diets. For Southern Pecan, the 'flavored' status is clear, but the exact nature of the 'high-quality essences' used is not detailed.

