Two toys, two play styles
If you're looking for a cat toy that sparks play, the BUFF BABY boxing glove and the KOI TOY offer very different experiences. The BUFF BABY is a silicone teether designed for teething babies, but its soft, chewable material and dangling shape can also tempt a playful cat. The KOI TOY is a glowing, floating fish that lights up in water, making it a potential fascination for water-loving felines. This comparison helps you decide which toy fits your cat's personality and your home.
What the catalog tells us
-
BUFF BABY - Boxing Glove: Made of flexible, chewable, baby-safe silicone, this photo-worthy teething mitt comes packed in a gift-ready window box. The silicone material is safe for chewing, which appeals to cats that like to gnaw and bat at dangling objects. The boxing glove shape invites batting and pawing.
BUFF BABY - Boxing Glove
-
KOI TOY: This delightfully realistic floating koi lights up the second it touches water, glowing brilliantly in a rainbow of hues. The light-up feature and water activation make it a novel toy for cats that are curious about water or enjoy splashing. The soft silicone body is safe for batting.
KOI TOY
BUFF BABY Boxing Glove vs KOI TOY: Key differences
The main difference is how each toy engages a cat. The BUFF BABY is a stationary, chewable mitt that you can dangle or toss. The KOI TOY is a floating, light-up fish that activates in water, offering a dynamic visual and tactile experience.
- Play style: BUFF BABY works best for batting, chewing, and pawing on dry land. KOI TOY introduces water play with a glowing effect that can mesmerize cats.
- Material and safety: Both are made of soft silicone. BUFF BABY is explicitly baby-safe silicone. KOI TOY contains a sealed coin cell battery, which is non-replaceable but designed to be safe for kids of all ages. For cats, the sealed battery is a plus as it prevents ingestion, but always supervise play with electronic toys.
- Maintenance: BUFF BABY can be wiped clean. KOI TOY is water-activated, so it will need occasional rinsing and drying. The battery lasts about 40 hours of light, but once depleted, the toy stops glowing.
- Price: BUFF BABY costs USD 10.40 (catalog price USD 16.00). KOI TOY costs USD 14.20 (catalog price USD 20.00). The KOI TOY is slightly more expensive.
Which one for your cat?
Choose the BUFF BABY boxing glove if your cat enjoys batting at dangling toys, chewing on soft objects, or playing fetch. Its simple design and lack of electronics make it a low-maintenance option. Choose the KOI TOY if your cat is drawn to water, light, or movement. The glowing fish can be a fun bath toy for cats that like to splash, or even a pool toy for supervised outdoor play. Both toys are made of silicone, but the KOI TOY's battery means it won't last forever. Consider your cat's play habits and your willingness to supervise electronic toys.
Honest trade-offs
The BUFF BABY is not designed as a cat toy—it's a baby teether. While safe for cats, it lacks catnip or crinkle sounds that some cats prefer. The KOI TOY is a bath toy with a limited battery life; once the battery dies, the toy becomes a simple floating fish. Neither toy is a substitute for interactive play with you. For the best results, use either toy as part of a play session rather than leaving it out all day.




