Quick answer

Choose the Midi Cake Slice Hair Claw Clip if you want a lightweight, plant-based hair accessory that adds a subtle sweet touch to everyday styles. Choose the Carrie Cupcake Enamel Keychain if you prefer a small, shiny bag charm that clips onto keys or totes. For a coordinated dessert-themed look, pair them—but keep the rest of your outfit simple so the accessories stand out.

Size and hold: what each piece can do

The Midi Cake Slice Hair Claw Clip measures 2.75" x 2", making it a mid-size claw that works well for half-up styles or securing small sections of hair. The Carrie Cupcake Enamel Keychain is 2" x 2" and comes with a split ring, so it is designed for keys or bags rather than hair. If you need to sweep up a lot of hair, neither is a large claw—consider a large claw like the Large Confetti Cake Hair Claw Clip (4" x 3.25") for full updos.

Material and care: cellulose acetate vs enamel

The cake slice claw is handmade from cellulose acetate, a plant-based alternative to plastic, and hand-painted, so each piece has unique color variations. The cupcake keychain is enamel on metal (as implied by the name), giving it a shiny, durable finish. Neither product listing provides specific care instructions, so treat both gently: avoid dropping the claw and keep the keychain away from abrasive surfaces to preserve the enamel.

Styling together: dessert accessories pairing

Pairing a cake slice hair claw clip with a cupcake enamel keychain creates a playful, coordinated look. Because both are dessert-themed, let one be the focal point: if you wear the claw in your hair, keep the keychain on a simple bag. The keychain's pink color and the claw's colorful cake design can echo each other without matching exactly. For a more understated approach, choose one dessert accessory at a time.

Trade-offs to weigh

  • Hair vs bag: The claw is worn in hair; the keychain is clipped to bags or keys. Each serves a different purpose, so they don't compete for the same spot. Decide whether you want an accessory for your hair or your bag—or both for a coordinated look.
  • Size and hold: The midi claw (2.75" x 2") holds small sections; the keychain (2" x 2") is purely decorative. If you need to secure a lot of hair, the midi claw may be too small. For thick or long hair, consider a large claw like the Large Confetti Cake Hair Claw Clip.
  • Material and durability: Cellulose acetate is plant-based but can be sensitive to heat and rough handling; enamel is shiny but may chip if dropped. Neither comes with a warranty listed. Handle both with care to keep them looking their best.

Product facts

  • Midi Cake Slice Hair Claw Clip: Made from cellulose acetate, a plant-based alternative to plastic, and hand-painted with unique color variations. A lightweight, eco-conscious choice for a hair accessory that feels one-of-a-kind.
  • Carrie Cupcake Enamel Keychain: Measures 2" x 2" and comes with a split ring for clipping onto bags, purses, or keys. A small, versatile charm that adds a pop of sweetness without taking up much space.
  • Large Confetti Cake Hair Claw Clip: Large 4" x 3.25" claw made from cellulose acetate, part of the Sweet Treats collab with Magnolia Bakery. Offers a sturdier hold for more hair, ideal if you want a statement claw rather than a midi size.

Who should choose which

Best for

  • Shoppers who want a lightweight, plant-based hair accessory for half-up styles or fine hair.
  • Fans of subtle dessert-themed accessories who prefer a hair clip over a bag charm.

Not for

  • Anyone who needs a strong hold for thick or long hair—choose a large claw instead.
  • Shoppers looking for a keychain or bag charm rather than a hair accessory.