Quick answer

Choose the Caleb Widogast dice set if you want a fiery, wizardly look with sharp-edged dice and a custom flame d20. Choose the Percy de Rolo set if you prefer a debonair dark blue and gold palette with a Whitestone crest d20. Both are official Critical Role Champion Dice Sets, so your decision comes down to character affinity and aesthetic.

Design and character inspiration

The Caleb set draws on the wizard's fiery magic: swirling maroon red and bright flame blue epoxy, red iridescent foil, and gold debossed numbering. The d20 shows a flame icon inspired by Caleb. The Percy set channels the gunslinger's refined style: dark blue and metallic light blue with rich gold foil, copper embossed numbering, and a Whitestone crest on the d20. Neither set includes character-specific gameplay rules; they are aesthetic upgrades for your dice collection.

Dice feel and readability

The Caleb set uses sharp-edged dice, which many players associate with a satisfying, crisp roll. The Percy set's finish is described as 'debonair math rocks' with metallic copper numbering. Both use high-contrast numbering against their backgrounds, but the Percy set's lighter blue areas may offer slightly better visibility in low light. The Caleb set's darker maroon and swirling foil can make the numbers less prominent at a glance. Neither set's exact dimensions or weight are listed, so if you prefer a specific dice size or heft, you may need to handle them in person or check the product page for additional details.

Value and collectibility

At the time of writing, the Caleb set is listed at $18.74 (compared to $24.99), while the Percy set is $16.99 (compared to $24.99). Both are part of the Champion Dice Set line, which typically includes a full polyhedral set. The Percy set is currently the lower-priced option, but both offer savings off the comparison price. If you're choosing between them, consider which character you're more likely to play or display. Collectors may want both, but if you're buying one, pick the one that matches your character concept or favorite campaign.

Key trade-offs

  • Aesthetic vs. readability: The Caleb set's swirling foil and dark base create a dramatic look but may reduce number contrast. The Percy set's lighter blue sections and copper numbering offer better visibility in dim lighting. If you often play in low light, prioritize the Percy set for easier reading.
  • Character connection: Both sets include a custom d20 icon tied to their character. Choose the character you identify with more or the one you're currently playing. Consider your current campaign or favorite Critical Role character before deciding.
  • Price and availability: The Percy set is currently listed at a lower price than the Caleb set. Both are discounted from their comparison prices, but stock may vary. If budget is tight, the Percy set offers similar quality at a lower cost.

Product facts

  • Critical Role Champion Dice Set: Caleb Widogast: Sharp-edged dice cast in swirling maroon red and bright flame blue epoxy with red iridescent foil and gold debossed numbering; custom d20 features a Caleb Widogast-inspired flame icon. The sharp edges and fiery palette appeal to players who want a dice set that feels as intense as a wizard's spellcasting.

    Critical Role Champion Dice Set: Caleb Widogast

    Critical Role Champion Dice Set: Caleb Widogast

  • Critical Role Champion Dice Set: Percival Fredrickstein Von Musel Klossowski De Rolo III: Dark blue and metallic light blue dice with rich gold foil, metallic copper embossed numbering, and a custom Percy-inspired Whitestone crest on the d20. The elegant color scheme and crest make this set a fitting choice for fans of the dapper gunslinger or anyone who prefers a refined table presence.

    Critical Role Champion Dice Set: Percival Fredrickstein Von Musel Klossowski De Rolo III

    Critical Role Champion Dice Set: Percival Fredrickstein Von Musel Klossowski De Rolo III

Which set should you choose?

Best for

  • Players who love wizards and fiery aesthetics
  • Fans of Caleb Widogast or Campaign 2
  • Those who prefer sharp-edged dice with a dramatic look

Not for

  • Players who need maximum number readability in low light
  • Fans of Percy or Vox Machina (choose the Percy set instead)
  • Collectors who already own the Percy set and want variety