What to Expect from Charcoal and Natural Toothpastes
When you're choosing between a charcoal toothpaste and a natural toothpaste, the real difference lies in how each formula approaches cleaning and whitening. Both options avoid synthetic detergents and artificial additives, but their active ingredients and texture can lead to a noticeably different brushing experience.
How They Clean: Charcoal vs Natural Formula
The Davids Charcoal + Peppermint Premium Toothpaste relies on ultra-fine activated charcoal derived from coconut shells, paired with gentle micro-abrasives like calcium carbonate and hydrated silica. This combination is designed to lift surface stains while helping reduce plaque buildup. The charcoal itself does not foam heavily, but the peppermint and spearmint oils provide a fresh finish.
Dr. Bronner's Cinnamon All-One Toothpaste takes a different path. Its formula uses organic coconut flour and fair trade organic coconut oil to gently remove plaque and whiten teeth, supported by organic aloe to soothe gums. The cleaning action is low-foaming and relies on the mechanical action of brushing with hydrated silica and calcium carbonate, without any charcoal or synthetic foaming agents.
- Davids Charcoal + Peppermint: Ultra-fine coconut-shell charcoal plus gentle micro-abrasives for stain lifting and plaque reduction. Contains xylitol (birch derived) and natural oils for breath freshness.
- Dr. Bronner's Cinnamon All-One: Organic coconut flour and coconut oil for plaque removal and whitening, plus organic aloe for gum soothing. No charcoal, no synthetic foaming agents.
What the Product Records Show
-
Davids Charcoal + Peppermint Premium Toothpaste 5.25oz: Davids Premium Toothpaste is fluoride-free, SLS-free, and EWG VERIFIED™. Activated charcoal works with gentle micro-abrasives to help lift surface stains. If you want a toothpaste that targets surface stains from coffee or tea, the charcoal + micro-abrasive combination is a direct approach.
Davids Charcoal + Peppermint Premium Toothpaste 5.25oz
-
Dr. Bronner's Cinnamon All-One Toothpaste 5oz: Dr. Bronner's All-One Toothpaste is made from 70% organic ingredients, fluoride-free and SLS-free, with organic cinnamon oil and menthol crystals for flavor and freshness. For those who prefer a simpler, plant-based formula without charcoal, this provides effective cleaning with organic ingredients and a warm cinnamon flavor.
Dr. Bronner's Cinnamon All-One Toothpaste 5oz
Flavor and Texture Differences
Davids Charcoal + Peppermint delivers a classic minty experience with peppermint, spearmint, and a hint of anise and wintergreen. The texture is creamy but not overly foamy, and the charcoal gives it a dark gray color that may temporarily darken your brush head.
Dr. Bronner's Cinnamon All-One stands out with a warm, spicy cinnamon flavor balanced by natural menthol crystals for a cooling finish. It is low-foaming and has a lighter, gel-like consistency. The cinnamon taste is more pronounced than typical mint toothpastes, which some people find refreshing and others may need time to adjust to.
Which One Should You Choose?
Your choice depends on your priorities. If you are concerned about surface stains and want a toothpaste that explicitly targets whitening through activated charcoal, Davids Charcoal + Peppermint is a solid option. It also includes xylitol, a natural sweetener that may help with oral hygiene.
If you prefer a straightforward natural formula with organic ingredients, no charcoal, and a distinctive cinnamon flavor, Dr. Bronner's Cinnamon All-One offers a gentle, effective clean. It is also vegan and cruelty-free, with no carrageenan or synthetic sweeteners.




