Two Jac-Shirts, Two Approaches
Filson's Jac-Shirt design has been a dependable staple since the 1970s, blending the cut of a shirt with the weight of a jacket. The Clarkston Jac-Shirt and the Women's Field Jac-Shirt both carry that heritage, but they serve different needs. This comparison looks at fabric, fit, and features to help you decide which overshirt fits your wardrobe.
At a Glance: Key Differences
-
Clarkston Jac-shirt: Made with densely woven Bedford cord, a durable fabric with British roots. Densely woven with a notable vertical rib, it's been used for military uniforms and workwear for miners and railroad workers. The Clarkston uses a rugged, tightly woven cotton that resists abrasion and has a distinct vertical texture. It's built for heavy use and outdoor work.
Clarkston Jac-shirt
-
Women's Field Jac-shirt: The midweight cotton fabric is a reverse-sateen weave, smooth on the inside for easy layering. The Women's Field Jac-Shirt uses a midweight reverse-sateen weave that feels smooth against base layers, making it comfortable for all-day wear over a tee or under a coat.
Women's Field Jac-shirt
Fabric and Weight: Bedford Cord vs Reverse-Sateen
The Clarkston Jac-Shirt is made from Bedford cord, a densely woven cotton with a pronounced vertical rib. This fabric has a history in military and workwear, so it stands up to repeated wear and rough conditions. The Women's Field Jac-Shirt uses a midweight reverse-sateen weave. It's smooth on the inside, which makes it easier to layer over a shirt or under a jacket without bunching. If you need a tough outer layer for chores or the trail, the Clarkston's Bedford cord is the heavier option. For a more flexible overshirt that layers comfortably, the Women's Field Jac-Shirt is the better choice.
Fit and Intended Use
The Clarkston Jac-Shirt has a straight hem designed for untucked wear, with chip-resistant buttons securing the front and adjustable cuffs. Chest pockets are protected by buttoned flaps. This is a unisex-style shirt-jacket meant to be worn as an outer layer. The Women's Field Jac-Shirt is patterned after the iconic Jac-Shirt but cut specifically for women. It also has a straight hem and sturdy buttons on the front, pocket flaps, and duffs. The reverse-sateen fabric is smooth inside for easy layering, and it's designed as a versatile overshirt for cool days. Both have a shirt-like cut, but the Women's Field version is tailored to a woman's proportions, while the Clarkston offers a more traditional, boxy fit.
Features Comparison
- Clarkston Jac-shirt: Chip resistant buttons secure the front and adjustable cuffs. Chest pockets are protected by buttoned flaps. The hem is straight for untucked wear. Adjustable cuffs let you customize the sleeve fit, and chip-resistant buttons add durability. The straight hem keeps the shirt from riding up when worn untucked.
- Women's Field Jac-shirt: Sturdy buttons secure the front, pocket flaps, and duffs. Straight hem. The Women's Field Jac-Shirt uses sturdy buttons throughout, including on the pocket flaps and duffs, adding durability to the closure points. The straight hem is designed for untucked wear.
Color and Size Availability
The Clarkston Jac-Shirt is available in XS in Labrador Brown and Surplus Green. The Women's Field Jac-Shirt comes in XS and S in Cedar Red and Feather Gray. If you need a wider size range or more color options, the Women's Field Jac-Shirt currently offers more variety, while the Clarkston is limited to two colors and one size per color.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose the Clarkston Jac-Shirt if you want a rugged, workwear-inspired overshirt with a traditional fit and durable Bedford cord fabric. It's ideal for outdoor tasks or as a heavy layer on cool days. Choose the Women's Field Jac-Shirt if you prefer a midweight overshirt that layers smoothly and is cut for a woman's frame. Its reverse-sateen fabric is comfortable against the skin and versatile enough for casual wear or as a mid-layer under a heavier coat.




