Two refillable nudes, two different finishes
If you're choosing between Zao's refillable nude lipsticks, the first decision is finish: a comfortable balm-like bullet or a liquid matte. The Cocoon Balm Lipstick Nude Collection in Brownish Pink 416 sits halfway between a lipstick and a lip balm, while the Lip Ink Nude Collection in Nude Pink 445 is a liquid matt lipstick built for a long-lasting, opaque finish. Both are available as refills, so the comparison below focuses on what each formula and shade actually delivers.
Cocoon Balm 416 vs Lip Ink 445 at a glance
- Finish: Cocoon Balm 416: halfway between a lipstick and a lip balm, with intense colour and comfort. Lip Ink 445: liquid matt, opaque and intense.
- Shade: Cocoon Balm 416 is a brownish pink. Lip Ink 445 is a matt nude pink with peach undertones, introduced as part of Zao's Nude Lips collection 2023.
- Wear profile: Lip Ink is described as long-lasting and durable, ideal for big occasions or long days. Cocoon Balm is presented as a caring, glide-on formula rather than a long-wear product.
- Key ingredients: Cocoon Balm includes organic pomegranate extract, organic shea butter, organic castor oil, organic carnauba wax and jojoba oil. Lip Ink includes organic castor oil, carnauba wax and tocopherol (vitamin E).
- Format: Both products are refills. Cocoon Balm 416 refills the Cocoon Balm Lipstick Nude Collection – Brownish Pink 416; Lip Ink 445 refills the Lip Ink Nude Collection – Nude Pink 445.
- Packaging note: Both refills come in plastic that is easily and fully recyclable, and Zao are working towards replacing this plastic with card or paper in the future.
What the Cocoon Balm refill brings to your lips
-
Refill Cocoon Balm Lipstick Nude Collection – Brownish Pink 416: A handy refill for your Zao Cocoon Balm Lipstick Nude Collection – Brownish Pink 416. This is the refill only, so it is designed to top up an existing Cocoon Balm case rather than arrive as a standalone lipstick.
Refill Cocoon Balm Lipstick Nude Collection – Brownish Pink 416
-
Refill Cocoon Balm Lipstick Nude Collection – Brownish Pink 416: Halfway between a lipstick and a lip balm, Cocoon glides onto your lips, bringing an intense colour with comfort and care for lips. This is the core trade-off: you get balm-like comfort and glide, not the long-wear matte performance of a liquid lipstick.
-
Refill Cocoon Balm Lipstick Nude Collection – Brownish Pink 416: Enriched with organic pomegranate extract and organic shea butter, the formula soothes and repairs lips. These are the caring ingredients behind the balm side of the formula, useful if comfort matters more to you than all-day hold.
What the Lip Ink refill is built for
-
Refill Lip Ink Nude Collection – Nude Pink 445: A handy refill for your Lip Ink Nude Collection – Nude Pink 445. Like the Cocoon refill, this is a refill only and needs the matching Lip Ink case to use.
Refill Lip Ink Nude Collection – Nude Pink 445
Refill Lip Ink Nude Collection – Nude Pink 445
-
Refill Lip Ink Nude Collection – Nude Pink 445: The Lip Inks are liquid matt lipsticks designed to create a long-lasting, opaque and intense finish. This is the main reason to choose Lip Ink over Cocoon Balm: a matte, high-coverage result that is meant to last.
-
Refill Lip Ink Nude Collection – Nude Pink 445: 445 Nude Pink is a matt nude pink with peach undertones, created to complement your complexion. The peach undertone gives you a warmer nude option compared with the brownish pink of Cocoon Balm 416.
Ingredients: caring balm vs durable matte
The ingredient lists reflect the two finishes. Cocoon Balm 416 leans on organic shea butter, organic pomegranate extract, organic castor oil, organic carnauba wax and jojoba oil; the record describes pomegranate as rich in punicic acid with soothing qualities and phytosterols with antioxidant properties, while shea butter and jojoba oil are included for softening and moisturising. Lip Ink 445 keeps organic castor oil for moisturising, carnauba wax for durability and protection, and tocopherol as a natural antioxidant. Both are described as talc-free, paraben-free and using micronised silver as a preservative, and Zao states it does not use nanoparticles. Neither record supplies a full ingredient list, so if you have known sensitivities, check the complete packaging before buying.
Which nude refill fits your routine?
- Choose Cocoon Balm 416 if…: You want a comfortable, balm-like bullet with a brownish pink tone and caring ingredients such as shea butter and pomegranate. It suits everyday wear where glide and comfort matter more than matte hold.
- Choose Lip Ink 445 if…: You need a long-lasting, opaque matte for a long day or a big occasion, and you like a nude pink with peach undertones.
- Consider both if…: You already own both refillable cases, or you want a caring daytime balm and a durable matte for evenings. Each refill only fits its own product line.
Practical limitations to know before you refill
Both products are refills, so they require the corresponding Zao case; the supplied records do not describe the case or how to insert the refill, so check the packaging or Zao's instructions when yours arrives. The records also do not give wear times, application tips, or a patch-test result, so treat any specific longevity claim as unconfirmed. For hygiene reasons, the store cannot refund these products once purchased, so it is worth being sure about the shade and finish before you order. The refills themselves come in recyclable plastic while Zao works towards card or paper packaging, which is a small environmental trade-off to weigh if plastic-free packaging is a priority for you.



