Two Daggerheart Dice Sets, Two Different Experiences

Choosing a Daggerheart dice set often comes down to how you want the dice to feel and look at the table. The Midnight Domain Multifaceted Dice Set and the Daggerheart: Hope & Fear Brawler Dice Set serve different players, even though both are officially licensed and built for the Daggerheart system.

The Midnight Domain set uses glass and includes a Hope die and a Fear die, matching the core Daggerheart mechanic. The Brawler set uses a white base with InkFX graphics and also includes specialized Hope and Fear d12s, but with a metallic gold and opalescent purple finish that stands out from the class dice.

Midnight Domain Dice Set at a Glance

Brawler Dice Set at a Glance

  • Daggerheart: Hope & Fear Dice Set - Brawler: This 9-die set includes a d4, d6, d8, d10, percentile die, d12, d20, plus a metallic gold Hope d12 and an opalescent purple Fear d12. The two specialty d12s are visually distinct from the white class dice, making it easy to spot Hope and Fear results at a glance.

    Daggerheart: Hope & Fear Dice Set - Brawler

    Daggerheart: Hope & Fear Dice Set - Brawler

  • Daggerheart: Hope & Fear Dice Set - Brawler: The Brawler set uses white base dice with bold orange, yellow, black, and gray InkFX graphics, featuring class artwork by Kayla VanProoyen. The artwork and high-contrast numbering improve readability, especially on a busy tabletop.

  • Daggerheart: Hope & Fear Dice Set - Brawler: This is Botch Dice's first metallic gold Hope d12 and first opalescent purple Fear d12. Collectors and players who want unique dice may value these first-edition finishes.

How Material and Theme Affect Your Choice

The biggest difference is material. The Midnight Domain set is glass, which feels premium but is more fragile. The Brawler set is a standard resin-like material with InkFX graphics, making it more durable for regular play.

Theme also matters. Midnight Domain suits a shadowy, magic-themed character, while Brawler is designed for the Brawler class from Daggerheart: Hope & Fear. If you're playing a Brawler or want dice that match that class, the Brawler set is the clear pick. If you prefer a more general dark aesthetic, the Midnight Domain set works for any character.

Price is another factor. The Midnight Domain set has a catalog price of USD 74.79, while the Brawler set is USD 36.84. The glass set costs more due to the material and the included storage box.

  • Material and durability: Midnight Domain is glass; Brawler is resin with InkFX. Glass is heavier and smoother but can chip; resin is more durable for frequent rolling.
  • Class vs. general theme: Brawler set is tied to the Brawler class; Midnight Domain is a shadow-themed set that fits any character.
  • Price: Midnight Domain: USD 74.79; Brawler: USD 36.84.
  • Hope and Fear dice: Both sets include dedicated Hope and Fear d12s. Midnight Domain uses glass; Brawler uses metallic gold and opalescent purple finishes.

Which Set Should You Choose?

If you want a durable, class-themed set that's easy to read and fits the Brawler aesthetic, go with the Brawler dice set. It's also more affordable and better for regular use.

If you prefer a premium glass set with a darker, more mysterious look and are willing to handle it carefully, the Midnight Domain set offers a different tactile experience. The lifetime warranty adds peace of mind for glass dice.

Both sets are shipped by different licensing partners and are only available to US addresses. Check the product pages for current availability.