Quick answer

For most shoppers, the Loving Joy Dart offers the best balance of price and versatility with its removable bullet, while the LELO Surfer 2 is the clear pick for app control and seamless silicone. The Paragon sits between them as a straightforward 7-function plug.

Price and what you get

The Dart and Paragon are both budget-friendly options under $12, and each includes a removable bullet vibrator that doubles as a standalone mini vibe. The Surfer 2 is a significant investment at $60.99, but it adds app control and a seamless silicone body. If you're new to vibrating plugs, the lower-cost options let you experiment without committing a lot of money.

Vibration control and features

The Dart and Paragon both offer 7 functions, giving you a range of patterns and intensities to explore. The Surfer 2 provides four manual vibration modes plus app control, which allows for custom patterns and remote operation. The app adds a layer of convenience and partner play possibilities that the budget options can't match. However, if you prefer simple push-button control, the Dart or Paragon may be more straightforward.

Material and care

The Surfer 2's seamless silicone over an ABS core means no crevices for moisture to collect, and it's fully submersible for bath or shower use. The Dart and Paragon are also silicone but have textured surfaces and removable bullets, which require more careful cleaning around the bullet compartment. For easy maintenance and water play, the Surfer 2 has a clear edge.

Key trade-offs to weigh

  • Budget vs features: The Dart and Paragon cost under $12 and include 7 functions, while the Surfer 2 costs $60.99 but adds app control and a seamless body. Decide if advanced features justify the higher price. Set a budget first; if app control isn't essential, the budget options perform well.
  • Control method: The Dart and Paragon use simple buttons to cycle through 7 functions. The Surfer 2 offers four manual modes plus app control for custom patterns and remote use. Choose based on whether you prefer tactile buttons or smartphone control. Consider whether you'll actually use app features or prefer straightforward button operation.
  • Cleaning and water play: The Surfer 2's seamless silicone and submersible design make it easier to clean and safe for bath or shower use. The Dart and Paragon have removable bullets and textured surfaces that require more attention during cleaning and aren't specified as submersible. If you want hassle-free cleaning or water play, the Surfer 2 is the safer choice.

Product facts

Which one is right for you?

Best for

  • Shoppers who want a versatile, budget-friendly vibrating plug with a removable bullet (Dart)
  • Users who prefer app control, seamless silicone, and water play (Surfer 2)
  • Anyone seeking a simple 7-function plug with a contoured fit (Paragon)

Not for

  • Those who need app control or submersible design on a tight budget
  • Users who dislike removable bullets or textured surfaces
  • People who want the simplest possible cleaning routine