Quick answer

Start with the colour and character that fits the child or collector, then use price to decide: Lily and Magnolia are the lowest-priced at USD 21.44, Violet is USD 21.76 and Iris is USD 22.40. If you are buying a first Dinky Dinkum, Lily is the gentlest all-round choice; if you want a limited-edition piece, choose Violet.

Colour and character are the real deciding factors

All four dolls share the same pocket-sized Dinky Dinkum format, so the meaningful differences are the outfit colour and the personality described in each listing. Lily is pale green and soft white, Violet is a soft violet romper, Magnolia wears sorbet-pink florals and Iris has a blue twirly dress. Match the doll to a favourite colour or to the kind of play you expect: quiet cuddles, floral-themed imaginative play or a bright, ready-to-go companion.

Price differences are small, but they matter for multiples

The gap between the cheapest and most expensive doll is under one dollar at catalog price, so price alone should not decide a single purchase. It becomes more useful when you are buying two or more: choosing Lily or Magnolia keeps a small collection slightly cheaper, while Iris costs the most of the four. All four are listed with a comparison price of USD 32.00, so the current prices represent a similar saving across the range.

Limited editions and collection appeal

Violet is described as a limited-edition Dinky Dinkum, which makes her the one to choose if you are buying for a collector who values scarcity. Magnolia and Iris are presented as part of a floral-inspired collection, so they pair naturally if you are building a themed shelf. Lily is framed as a timeless, tender friend rather than a limited piece, which suits a first doll or a gift where long-term availability matters more than rarity.

Decision rules for choosing your Dinky Dinkum

  • If it is a first Dinky Dinkum: Choose Lily. Her pale green and white outfit and tender character make her the most neutral starting point, and she is tied for the lowest price at USD 21.44. A first doll should feel easy to love before it feels collectible.
  • If you are buying for a collector: Choose Violet. She is the only one of the four described as limited-edition, so she is the strongest pick when rarity matters more than colour matching. Limited-edition status is the clearest reason to buy Violet over the others.
  • If you want a themed set: Pair Magnolia and Iris. Magnolia's sorbet-pink floral outfit and Iris's blue twirly dress both belong to the floral-inspired collection, so they display well together. Buying two from the floral collection creates a coordinated gift or shelf pair.
  • If budget is the deciding factor: Choose Lily or Magnolia at USD 21.44 each. Violet is USD 21.76 and Iris is USD 22.40, so the saving is small per doll but adds up when buying several. Set a total budget before choosing a colour, not after.
  • If you are unsure about colour: Ask the child's favourite colour first. Lily is green and white, Violet is purple, Magnolia is pink floral and Iris is blue, so the answer usually settles the choice immediately. One question about colour prevents most gift returns.

The four Dinky Dinkums at a glance

  • Dinky Dinkums - Lily: Lily is dressed in pale green and soft white and described as tender and timeless. The neutral palette and gentle character make her an easy first doll or a safe gift when you are unsure of a child's favourite colour.

    Dinky Dinkums - Lily

    Dinky Dinkums - Lily

  • Dinky Dinkums - Violet: Violet is a limited-edition Dinky Dinkum in a soft violet romper. Choose her when you want a collectible piece that may not stay available, rather than a doll bought purely for everyday play.

    Dinky Dinkums - Violet

    Dinky Dinkums - Violet

  • Dinky Dinkums - Magnolia: Magnolia wears a sorbet-pink floral outfit and is part of the floral Dinky Dinkum collection. She suits floral-themed play and shelf displays, and pairs naturally with Iris if you are building a coordinated set.

  • Dinky Dinkums - Iris: Iris has a blue twirly dress and is described as portable and collectible. Her bright colour and pocket-sized design make her a good choice for a doll that travels in a tote or sits on a bookshelf.

Who these Dinky Dinkums suit

Best for

  • Buying a first soft doll for a young child
  • A small gift where colour and character matter more than size
  • Collectors who want a limited-edition piece or a floral-themed shelf

Not for

  • Shoppers who need a larger doll for big cuddles or outfit changes
  • Buyers who want one doll to cover every colour preference
  • Anyone looking for a doll with supplied age or safety ratings, which are not listed here