Two small friends, one clear decision
Magnolia and Lily are both part of the Dinky Dinkum line and both marked as Small First Release, so if you're choosing a small plush baby gift, the decision comes down to character, color, and price rather than size or format. The catalog describes Magnolia as dressed in a sorbet-pink floral outfit with a little twinkle in her eyes, while Lily wears pale green and soft white and is framed as the tender, secret-keeping friend.
That difference in mood is the most useful starting point. Magnolia reads brighter and more floral; Lily reads calmer and more classic. Neither is presented as better than the other, and the supplied information does not rank them, so treat this as a style choice for the recipient rather than a quality verdict.
What the catalog confirms about Magnolia
-
Dinky Dinkums - Magnolia: Part of the floral Dinky Dinkum collection and dressed in a sorbet-pink floral outfit. If you want a gift with a distinctly floral, spring-like look, Magnolia is the clearer match.
Dinky Dinkums - Magnolia
-
Dinky Dinkums - Magnolia: Described as pocket-sized, gentle, and made for magical everyday moments. These are the catalog's own words about scale and feel, useful when you want a small plush baby gift rather than a larger plush.
-
Dinky Dinkums - Magnolia: Listed at USD 19.84, with a catalog comparison price of USD 32.00. At the listed price, Magnolia is the lower-cost of the two in the supplied catalog, which matters if budget shapes the gift.
What the catalog confirms about Lily
-
Dinky Dinkums - Lily: Clothed in pale green and soft white and described as tender, timeless, and easy to adore. Lily suits a gift where the color palette should stay soft and neutral rather than pink and floral.
Dinky Dinkums - Lily
-
Dinky Dinkums - Lily: Presented as a collectible Dinky Dinkum ready for memory-making from the very first cuddle. The catalog frames Lily around comfort and keepsake value, which fits a first-plush gift narrative.
-
Dinky Dinkums - Lily: Listed at USD 22.40, with a catalog comparison price of USD 32.00. Lily costs a little more than Magnolia at the listed prices, so the gap is small but real.
Magnolia vs Lily side by side
Both are Small First Release Dinky Dinkums with a Standard variant and a catalog comparison price of USD 32.00. The meaningful differences are color story, character framing, and the listed price.
- Color and outfit: Magnolia: sorbet-pink floral outfit, part of the floral Dinky Dinkum collection. Lily: pale green and soft white clothing.
- Character mood: Magnolia is framed as dreamy and adventurous; Lily is framed as tender and secret-keeping.
- Listed price: Magnolia is USD 19.84; Lily is USD 22.40. Both show a USD 32.00 comparison price.
- Format: Both are described as small, pocket-sized Dinky Dinkums in the Standard variant.
How to choose for a baby gift
If the gift is for a baby whose nursery or wardrobe leans pink and floral, Magnolia is the more coordinated choice, and it is also the cheaper option in the supplied catalog. If you want a softer, more neutral palette or a gift that leans on the idea of a gentle first friend, Lily fits that brief better.
Consider the giver's intent too. Magnolia's floral collection framing makes it feel like a seasonal or collection-driven pick, while Lily's tender, timeless framing makes it feel like a classic keepsake. Neither framing is a safety or suitability claim, so use it as tone guidance, not as a guarantee of how a baby will respond.
What the supplied information does not confirm
The supplied records do not include care instructions, safety certifications, age recommendations, or material specifications for either plush. That means this comparison cannot tell you whether either one is suitable for a newborn, how to wash it, or what it is stuffed with. If those details matter for your gift, check the product page or ask the store before buying rather than assuming.
The records also do not state dimensions beyond the word pocket-sized, so do not treat that as a measurement. Both products list only a Standard variant, so there is no size or color option to compare within each listing.




