Quick answer

Choose the Don Post Skull Plastic Mask for a classic, unisex spooky look that works with any costume, or the Don Post Witch Plastic Mask for a character-specific, story-driven Halloween outfit.

Design and character appeal

The Don Post Skull mask delivers a timeless, gender-neutral horror icon that pairs well with any dark outfit. Its skeletal face is instantly recognizable and requires no costume backstory. The Witch mask, on the other hand, leans into a specific folkloric character, making it ideal for someone who wants to embody a classic Halloween villain.

Both masks are injection-molded plastic reinterpretations of the original latex Don Post masks, giving them a retro-inspired look that collectors and costume enthusiasts appreciate.

Size and fit considerations

The Skull mask measures approximately 10 inches from top to bottom, while the Witch mask is about 11 inches tall. That extra inch on the Witch mask may provide slightly more coverage, but the difference is minimal for most adults.

Both masks feature an elastic strap for easy wearing, so you can take them on and off quickly during a night of trick-or-treating or at a costume party.

Skull vs Witch: trade-offs at a glance

  • Character specificity: The Witch mask is tied to a specific character, making it a strong choice for a witch costume. The Skull mask is more versatile and works with any scary or neutral outfit.
  • Size difference: The Witch mask is about 11 inches tall, one inch taller than the Skull mask. Both fit most adults, but the Witch offers slightly more coverage.
  • Display vs costume use: Both masks are great for display due to their retro design. For active costume wear, the elastic strap keeps them secure, but the Skull mask is less likely to clash with your clothing.

Product facts

  • Don Post - Witch Plastic Mask: This injection molded mask is a reimagining of the classic latex Don Post Witch Mask as a retro-inspired mask with an elastic strap. You get the vintage look of a classic Halloween mask without the weight and care requirements of latex, and the elastic strap makes it easy to put on and remove.

    Don Post - Witch Plastic Mask

    Don Post - Witch Plastic Mask

  • Don Post - Skull Plastic Mask: This injection molded mask is a reimagining of the classic latex Don Post Skull Mask as a retro-inspired mask with an elastic strap. The skull design is a universal horror icon that works for any costume theme, and the plastic construction is more durable and easier to store than latex.

    Don Post - Skull Plastic Mask

    Don Post - Skull Plastic Mask

Which mask fits you?

Best for

  • Halloween costume enthusiasts who want a classic, recognizable skull look that matches any dark outfit
  • Collectors of retro-inspired horror masks who appreciate the timeless design

Not for

  • Anyone seeking a highly detailed, screen-accurate prop mask — these are retro-style plastic masks, not movie replicas