Two windbreakers, two ride styles

When the wind picks up, a lightweight jacket can make the difference between a comfortable ride and a miserable one. Café du Cycliste offers two windproof options: the Edith and the Ilona. Both are ultra-light and packable, but they serve different priorities. This comparison focuses on what each jacket does best, so you can choose the right one for your rides.

At a glance: what the records confirm

  • Edith: Edith is made from an ultra-light recycled fabric. The front is fully windproof, while the back section is breathable for temperature control. It features a YKK two-way zipper and is highly packable. This design prioritizes wind protection where you need it most (front) and breathability where you generate heat (back), making it ideal for variable-effort rides.

    Edith

    Edith

  • Ilona: Ilona is an ultra-light ripstop fabric jacket with full wind protection, ventilation openings, and a helmet-compatible hood with visor. It folds into a jersey pocket. Ripstop durability and a hood make Ilona a better choice for longer, more unpredictable rides where you might encounter rain or need extra coverage.

    Ilona

    Ilona

Wind protection and ventilation

Both jackets block the wind, but they manage airflow differently.

  • Edith: The front is fully windproof, while the back panel is breathable. This design sheds heat when you're pushing hard, but it also means the back offers less wind resistance.
  • Ilona: The entire jacket is windproof, but it adds ventilation openings to let out excess heat. This gives you more control over airflow, especially during climbs or hard efforts.

Packability and portability

Both jackets are designed to be stashed when not needed, but the details differ.

  • Edith: Described as highly compactable, it's a minimalist companion for long days in the saddle. The YKK two-way zipper adds flexibility for layering or venting.
  • Ilona: Pliable and folds into a jersey pocket. The ripstop fabric adds durability, so it can handle being stuffed and pulled out repeatedly without wear.

Extra features: hood and storage

The Ilona includes features the Edith lacks, which may tip the scale for certain riders.

  • Edith: No hood. Two-way zipper for easy access. No pockets mentioned. Focuses on simplicity and weight savings.
  • Ilona: Helmet-compatible hood with visor. Two zippered pockets for storing essentials. Elastic hem for a secure fit.

Fit and sizing

Sizing availability may influence your choice. The supplied records show that Edith is available in XS and M, while Ilona offers a wider range from XS to XL. If you fall outside the Edith size range, Ilona is the only option from these two.

  • Edith: Available in XS and M based on current records. Fit information beyond size is not confirmed.
  • Ilona: Available in XS, S, M, L, and XL. The ripstop fabric may have a slightly different feel, but specific fit details are not provided.

Which one should you choose?

If you want the lightest, most packable option for rides where you'll be working hard and need back breathability, the Edith is a strong choice. Its recycled fabric and simple design keep weight and bulk to a minimum.

If you need a hood, more storage, and the ability to control ventilation, the Ilona is the better all-rounder. Its ripstop fabric adds durability for daily use, and the helmet-compatible hood makes it versatile for changing weather.

Neither jacket's care instructions or thermal performance are confirmed by the supplied information, so treat both as lightweight wind shells rather than insulated layers.