Two Classic Organic Black Teas, Two Different Directions

If you are choosing between English Breakfast Organic and Earl Grey Organic, you are deciding between two well-loved black tea styles. Both come from Clipper Ship Tea Company and are certified organic, but each offers a distinct cup. English Breakfast is a smooth, balanced blend built for versatility. Earl Grey is an aromatic black tea scented with bergamot oil. Which one fits your morning (or afternoon) routine depends on how you like to drink your tea.

Flavor and Aroma at a Glance

Both teas are blends of black teas, but their flavor profiles differ significantly.

  • English Breakfast Organic: Tasting notes describe it as smooth and balanced. It is a classic black tea with a full orange pekoe leaf, sturdy enough to take milk yet light enough to sip straight or with lemon. Compared to Irish or Scottish breakfast teas, English Breakfast has a lighter body and a soft, balanced flavor that is not overpowering.
  • Earl Grey Organic: This tea is described as a classic aromatic earl grey. It blends rich Indian black tea with premium Italian bergamot oil, giving it a distinctive citrusy floral note. It can be enjoyed straight up, with lemon, or with milk and sugar. The bergamot makes it instantly recognizable.

What the Catalog Confirms About Each Tea

  • English Breakfast Organic: English Breakfast Organic is a blend of organic black teas from India, China, and Sri Lanka (Ceylon). Its origins date back to the 1800s clipper ship trade. The blend of Keemun, Assam, and Ceylon teas creates a balanced cup that appeals to a wide range of palates. The historical context explains why this blend exists.

    English Breakfast Organic

    English Breakfast Organic

  • Earl Grey Organic: Earl Grey Organic contains organic black tea and bergamot oil. Steep directions: 1 heaping teaspoon per 8 oz boiling water (205-212°F) for 3-4 minutes. Bergamot oil is the defining ingredient. The steeping time is shorter than English Breakfast, which steeps 3-5 minutes, so timing matters for the best cup.

    Earl Grey Organic

    Earl Grey Organic

Brewing Instructions and Tips

Both teas use the same basic brewing method: steep 1 heaping teaspoon of tea per 8 oz of boiling water (205-212°F). English Breakfast Organic should steep for 3-5 minutes, while Earl Grey Organic steeps for 3-4 minutes. The shorter steep for Earl Grey helps keep the bergamot flavor bright without becoming bitter. English Breakfast can handle a longer steep if you prefer a stronger cup, especially if you add milk.

Both teas are versatile enough to be enjoyed plain, with lemon, or with milk and sugar. The choice often comes down to whether you want a straightforward black tea (English Breakfast) or one with a distinct citrus aroma (Earl Grey).

How to Choose Between Them

If you want a classic breakfast tea that pairs well with food and can be dressed up with milk or lemon, English Breakfast Organic is the reliable choice. Its smooth, balanced flavor is hard to dislike. If you prefer a tea with a more pronounced aromatic character—something that stands out on its own—Earl Grey Organic delivers that bergamot note every time.

Both are available in sizes from 50g (1.8oz) to 454g (16oz), so you can try a small tin before committing to a larger quantity. Neither is a wrong choice; it is simply a matter of whether you want a traditional black tea blend or a flavored classic.