Quick answer
Choose the Evil Eye Enamel Keychain if you want a compact, protective symbol with a classic look; choose the Rainbow Butterfly Enamel Keychain if you prefer a wider, colorful charm that adds a playful pop to bags or keys.
Size and shape: how they sit on your gear
The Evil Eye keychain is 2.25 inches tall by 1.25 inches wide, so it stays narrow and vertical—less likely to snag or crowd a key ring. The Rainbow Butterfly is 2.25 inches wide, giving it a broader, horizontal spread that reads clearly from a distance but may feel bulkier on a tight keychain.
Both attach with a split key ring, so switching between keys, bags, or backpacks is equally easy. The difference is purely how much visual space the charm takes up.
Meaning and style: protection vs playfulness
The Evil Eye is traditionally associated with protection and warding off negative energy, which makes it a meaningful, understated choice for everyday carry. The Rainbow Butterfly leans into whimsy and color, with a vibrant rainbow design that resists fading thanks to its enamel construction.
Neither is inherently better—your pick depends on whether you want a subtle symbol with a story or a bright accessory that lifts your mood.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Space on your key ring: If you carry many keys or fobs, the Evil Eye’s 1.25-inch width leaves more room; the Rainbow Butterfly’s 2.25-inch width takes up more space but is easier to spot. Test your key ring with a similarly sized object before committing.
- Symbolism vs color: The Evil Eye offers a classic protective meaning; the Rainbow Butterfly offers a playful, colorful look. Pick the one that matches the message you want your accessory to send.
- Gift appeal: For a small, meaningful gift, the Evil Eye suits someone who appreciates tradition; the Rainbow Butterfly suits someone who loves bright, whimsical accessories. Both come from These Are Things and use durable enamel. Consider the recipient’s usual style before choosing.
Product facts
-
Rainbow Butterfly Enamel Keychain: Measures 2.25 inches wide (excluding the key ring) with a vibrant rainbow butterfly design. The wider profile makes it a visible, cheerful statement on a backpack or tote.
Rainbow Butterfly Enamel Keychain
-
Evil Eye Enamel Keychain: Measures 2.25 inches tall by 1.25 inches wide (excluding the key ring) and features an evil eye design. The narrow shape keeps it compact on a crowded key ring while still showing its protective symbol.
Evil Eye Enamel Keychain
Which one is right for you?
Best for
- Shoppers who want a compact, protective charm for everyday keys
- Gifts for someone who appreciates subtle symbolism and classic design
Not for
- People who prefer a bold, colorful accessory that stands out
- Anyone who needs a wider charm to easily spot in a bag