Quick answer

Choose Fist It Extra Thick for longer-lasting, cushioning glide during intense play; pick the standard Fist It for everyday versatility and a lighter feel.

What sets them apart

Both Fist It lubricants are water-based, dermatologically tested, and safe with latex condoms. The key difference is thickness: the Extra Thick formula provides more body and stays put longer, while the standard version offers a thinner, slicker application that's easier to spread over larger areas.

Neither product contains silicone, so they won't degrade silicone toys. Both are fat-free, colourless, odourless, and tasteless, making them suitable for sensitive skin and oral contact.

When thickness matters

Extra Thick lubricant is designed for activities where you want the lube to stay where you put it. Its higher viscosity reduces the need for reapplication during longer sessions and provides a plush, cushioning sensation. The standard formula, by contrast, is ideal for quick, light applications and general-purpose use.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Consistency: Extra Thick has a gel-like body that stays put; standard Fist It is thinner and flows more freely.
  • Reapplication frequency: Extra Thick lasts longer between reapplications; standard may need more frequent topping up. If you prefer set-and-forget lubrication, go Extra Thick.
  • Ease of application: Standard formula spreads quickly and evenly; Extra Thick requires a bit more effort to distribute. For quick, fuss-free application, standard is the better choice.

Product facts

  • Fist It - Extra Thick - 500 ml: Fist It - Extra Thick - 500 ml is a water-based lubricant suitable for use with latex condoms, dermatologically tested, fat-free, colourless, odourless and tasteless. The extra thickness means it stays in place longer, reducing reapplication during prolonged or vigorous play.

    Fist It - Extra Thick - 500 ml

    Fist It - Extra Thick - 500 ml

  • Fist It - 500ml: Fist It - 500ml is a water-based lubricant suitable for use with latex condoms, dermatologically tested, fat-free, colourless, odourless and tasteless. Its lighter consistency makes it easy to spread over large areas and ideal for general lubrication needs.

    Fist It - 500ml

    Fist It - 500ml

Which one fits you?

Best for

  • Intense or prolonged sessions where lube staying power is key
  • Users who want a cushioning, plush sensation during anal play

Not ideal for

  • Quick, light applications where a thin, spreadable lube is preferred
  • Those who dislike a thick, gel-like feel on the skin