Quick answer

Choose the Folk Cherry Bow Cardi for a playful cherry bow cardigan look with classic fit and rib details; choose the Nautical Shawl Collar Cardi for a dressier shawl collar cardigan for toddlers. Both are soft organic cotton with button fronts, so the real decision is style and neckline.

Style and neckline: the biggest visual difference

The Folk Cherry Bow Cardi features a rib neck, while the Nautical Shawl Collar Cardi has a shawl collar. That shawl collar gives a more elevated, layered look that works well for family gatherings or photos, but it also adds bulk around the neck. The cherry bow cardi’s rib neck keeps the neckline closer to the body, which can be easier for toddlers who dislike extra fabric near their chin.

Fit and sizing: same classic fit, same sizing advice

Both cardigans share a classic fit, and the brand suggests sizing up if you want an oversized fit. That means your usual size will fit close to the body, while one size up gives room for layering over tees or dresses. The shawl collar may feel slightly bulkier when sized up, so consider how much layering room your child actually needs.

Fabric and care: identical soft organic cotton

Both use soft organic cotton fabric, so neither has an advantage in breathability or hand-feel. Care instructions are not listed in the catalog for either style, so check the garment label when it arrives. As a general rule, organic cotton knits hold up well with gentle washing, but always follow the specific care tag to avoid shrinkage.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Playful vs. polished: The Folk Cherry Bow Cardi leans playful with its cherry bow detail, while the Nautical Shawl Collar Cardi reads more polished thanks to the shawl collar. Pick based on the occasions you dress your toddler for most.
  • Neckline comfort: The rib neck on the cherry bow cardigan sits closer to the neck, which some toddlers find less bothersome. The shawl collar offers a statement look but adds fabric around the neck—consider your child’s tolerance for that. If your toddler pulls at collars, the rib neck is the safer bet.
  • Sizing for layering: Both are classic fit, so sizing up gives an oversized look. With the shawl collar, sizing up may feel extra bulky around the shoulders; with the cherry bow, it creates a relaxed, roomy fit without extra neck fabric.

Product facts

  • Folk Cherry Bow Cardi Pink: Rib neck, cuffs, and hem with button closure front; classic fit (size up for oversized). The rib neck keeps the neckline neat and close-fitting, which suits toddlers who prefer less fabric around the neck.

    Folk Cherry Bow Cardi Pink

    Folk Cherry Bow Cardi Pink

  • Nautical Shawl Collar Cardi: Shawl collar with rib collar, cuffs, and hem; button closure front; classic fit (size up for oversized). The shawl collar adds a dressier look, but it may feel bulkier when layered or sized up.

    Nautical Shawl Collar Cardi

    Nautical Shawl Collar Cardi

Which cardigan for which child?

Best for

  • Toddlers who prefer a closer-fitting neckline and a playful cherry bow detail
  • Parents looking for a versatile everyday knit cardigan that layers easily

Not for

  • Those wanting a dressier, shawl-collar look for special occasions
  • Toddlers who are comfortable with extra fabric around the neck and need a more polished style