Quick answer

Choose Foulard Eau d'Italie #1 if you want the most substantial option in the collection and are comfortable spending USD 90. Choose Foulard Eau d'Italie #4 if you want the same handcrafted cotton quality at the lowest price, USD 72. Both are made in collaboration with Emporio Sirenuse and screen-printed in India, so the real difference is price and the specific print, not the craftsmanship.

What actually differs between #1 and #4

The two foulards share the same construction story: a collaboration with Emporio Sirenuse, cotton printed in India on screen-printing frames, and hand-finished with artisanal techniques applied to modern machinery. What changes is the price. Foulard #1 is listed at USD 90.00, while Foulard #4 is USD 72.00. Both carry a catalog comparison price of USD 120.00, so the discount is real but larger on #4 in absolute terms.

Because the catalog facts do not specify dimensions, fabric weight, or exact print names for either scarf, you should treat the print itself as the deciding visual factor. If you cannot see the scarves in person, compare the product images side by side and pick the print that matches the colors you already wear.

How to decide without seeing them in person

Start with your wardrobe, not the price tag. If your clothes lean neutral, either print will work, so let budget decide and take #4. If you are buying a foulard to be the focal point of an outfit, choose the print that feels boldest to you, since both scarves are designed to carry the colors of Eau d'Italie fragrances.

Second, consider how you will wear it. A cotton foulard printed on screen frames holds color well and works tied at the neck, on a bag handle, or as a light head covering. If you plan to wear it daily, the lower-priced #4 leaves more room in your budget for a second colorway. If it is a gift or a single statement piece, #1 justifies the higher price through its position in the collection.

Where #2 and #3 fit in the lineup

Foulard #1 and #4 are not your only options. Foulard #2 sits at USD 85.20 and Foulard #3 at USD 87.60, both against the same USD 120.00 comparison price. That means the collection spans roughly USD 72 to USD 90, and the mid-priced scarves can be the right answer if you love a print that is not #1 or #4.

Use the same logic across all four: the craftsmanship is described identically, so choose on print first, then on price. There is no catalog evidence that the more expensive scarves are made differently, so paying more is about the design you prefer, not about a higher grade of cotton.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Foulard #1 at USD 90.00: The top price in this two-way comparison, with the same cotton and screen-printing process as the cheaper scarves. You are paying for the specific print and its place in the collection. Best if this is the print you actually want and you are buying one scarf to keep.
  • Foulard #4 at USD 72.00: The lowest price of the pair, against a USD 120.00 comparison price. Identical craft story, so the saving does not come from a cheaper construction. Best if you want the Eau d'Italie look at the lowest entry price or plan to buy more than one.
  • The unknown: print and size: The catalog does not list dimensions, weight, or print names, so neither scarf can be judged on measurements from the listing alone. Compare product images carefully and choose the print that suits your wardrobe before comparing price.

Product facts

  • Foulard Eau d'Italie # 1: In collaborazione con Emporio Sirenuse, una collezione di bellissimi foulard in cotone, stampati in India su telai serigrafici con i colori dei profumi Eau d'Italie. Realizzati a mano con tecniche artigianali applicate a macchinari moderni. Confirms the cotton, screen-printed construction and the Emporio Sirenuse collaboration, so you know the higher price is not buying a different manufacturing method.
  • Foulard Eau d'Italie # 4: In collaborazione con Emporio Sirenuse, una collezione di bellissimi foulard in cotone, stampati in India su telai serigrafici con i colori dei profumi Eau d'Italie. Realizzati a mano con tecniche artigianali applicate a macchinari moderni. Shows the lowest-priced scarf in the comparison shares the exact same craft description, making it the value pick if you like its print.

Which foulard should you choose?

Choose Foulard #1 if

  • You want the most expensive print in this pairing and see it as a single statement piece
  • You are buying a gift and prefer the higher-end option in the collection
  • You already know the #1 print works with your wardrobe

Choose Foulard #4 instead if

  • You want the lowest price and the same handcrafted cotton construction
  • You plan to buy more than one foulard and want to spread your budget
  • You are new to the brand and prefer to start at the entry price