Two ways to buy the same Hidden Cherries gaff
The Gaff Tanga and the 3-Pack Gaff Tanga are both Hidden Cherries gaffs made in Quebec, with the same regular cut, black color, and fabric blend. The real decision is not which product is better, but how many you need and how much risk you want to take on fit. The single costs USD 37.20 (catalog comparison price USD 60.00); the 3-pack costs USD 126.00 (catalog comparison price USD 180.00). That works out to USD 42.00 per gaff in the pack versus USD 37.20 for one. The pack is not a per-unit discount, so the reason to buy it is having backups, not saving money per pair.
Price per gaff and what each option includes
- Gaff Tanga (single): USD 37.20, catalog comparison price USD 60.00. One black gaff in your chosen size.
- 3-Pack Gaff Tanga: USD 126.00, catalog comparison price USD 180.00. Three black gaffs, each in your chosen size. Per-unit price is USD 42.00, so you pay about USD 4.80 more per gaff than buying singles.
Sizing works the same way on both listings
Both products use waist measurements in inches, with sizes XS (26–29"), S (30–32"), M (33–35"), L (36–39"), XL (40–42"), XXL (43–45"), and 3XL (46–48"). The single listing shows M as 33–35"; the 3-pack listing shows M as 33–25", which appears to be a typo. Since the 3-pack is three identical gaffs, a sizing mistake there costs you three garments, not one. If you are between sizes or trying the cut for the first time, the single is the lower-risk way to confirm your measurement. The catalog does not state whether the gaff stretches with wear or how much compression each size provides, so your waist measurement is the only confirmed fit guide.
Care is hand-wash only, which affects how many you need
The catalog recommends hand washing to preserve the gaff's quality and shape. That matters for this comparison: hand washing means a worn gaff needs time to dry before you reach for it again. If you tuck daily, a 3-pack gives you a clean pair while others dry, without changing your care routine. If you tuck occasionally, one gaff may be enough, and you can add a second later. The fabric is 80% nylon and 20% spandex, with an inner lining of 80% cotton and 20% polyester. No other care instructions, drying guidance, or washing temperature are supplied, so follow the hand-wash recommendation and avoid guessing at machine settings.
What the catalog confirms for each option
-
Gaff Tanga: Gaff Tanga single: USD 37.20 (catalog comparison price USD 60.00), black, regular cut, made in Quebec, 80% nylon + 20% spandex with an 80% cotton + 20% polyester inner lining. This is the lowest-cost way to test the Hidden Cherries cut and sizing before committing to multiples.
Gaff Tanga
-
3-Pack Gaff Tanga: 3-Pack Gaff Tanga: USD 126.00 (catalog comparison price USD 180.00), three black gaffs in the same fabric and cut, with the same hand-wash recommendation. The pack costs USD 42.00 per gaff, so its value is convenience and backup pairs, not a lower unit price.
3-Pack Gaff Tanga
Final sale changes the math on the 3-pack
The catalog states that sales are final, with no exchanges, cancellations, or refunds. That policy applies to both products, but it weighs more heavily on the 3-pack because one sizing error affects three garments. If you already know your Hidden Cherries size, the pack is a straightforward way to build a rotation. If you do not, buy the single first. The listing also notes that taxes and customs fees may apply to international shipments, so check those costs before ordering from outside the country.
Tucking safety applies to both options
The catalog warns that tucking can carry risks including testicular complaints, effects on sperm production, discomfort, and poor blood circulation. It recommends following use instructions and tucking responsibly. Neither listing supplies a maximum wear time or a step-by-step tucking method, so the catalog does not give you a safe duration. If you feel discomfort or numbness, remove the gaff and reassess. This is general safety information from the listing, not a manufacturer instruction for a specific wear schedule.
Which one to buy first
Buy the single Gaff Tanga if you are new to this cut, unsure of your waist measurement, or tuck only occasionally. Buy the 3-Pack if you already know your size in Hidden Cherries, tuck most days, and want clean pairs available while others are hand-washed. The pack does not save you money per gaff, so choose it for the rotation, not the price. Either way, measure your waist in inches against the size chart before ordering, because final sale means you cannot exchange a poor fit.

