The real difference starts with the milk base

Both goat milk and cow milk first infant formulas are designed as breast milk substitutes for babies from birth to 6 months. The practical difference lies in the milk source and the ingredients each manufacturer chooses to include or leave out. Nannycare Stage 1 and Kendamil Stage 1 both use whole A2 goat milk, while Cow & Gate 1 uses a cow milk base. That base affects taste, the type of curds formed during digestion, and which added ingredients appear on the label.

None of the three products is automatically better. Your choice should depend on how your baby tolerates a formula, what ingredients you want to avoid, and how you prefer to prepare feeds. The product records below give you the confirmed facts to compare.

What the two goat milk options confirm

  • Nannycare Stage 1 Goat First Infant Goat Milk Formula 800g: Nannycare Stage 1 is made with premium whole A2 goat milk and includes added 2'FL fibre and plant-based DHA from algae. It is free from palm oil, soya, GMOs, added whey and fish oil. If you want a goat milk formula that avoids palm oil, soya and fish oil while still providing DHA, this record shows those choices are built in.

    Nannycare Stage 1 Goat First Infant Goat Milk Formula 800g

    Nannycare Stage 1 Goat First Infant Goat Milk Formula 800g

  • Kendamil Stage 1 Goat First Infant Milk From Birth 800g: Kendamil Stage 1 is made with whole A2 goat milk and goat whey, and contains whole milk fats and GOS. It is free from palm oil, fish oil, soya and maltodextrin. This option includes goat whey and GOS, which may suit parents looking for a goat milk formula with those specific ingredients.

    Kendamil Stage 1 Goat First Infant Milk From Birth 800g

    Kendamil Stage 1 Goat First Infant Milk From Birth 800g

Cow milk formula: what Cow & Gate 1 confirms

Cow & Gate 1 First Infant Milk is a cow milk-based formula from birth, supplied as a 1.2 kg pack made up of two 600 g units. The record notes it contains DHA and is palm oil free. It is positioned as a breastmilk substitute for bottle and breastfed babies and is designed to be used until moving to Follow-On Milk at 6 months.

The preparation instructions are more detailed than the goat milk records. They specify boiling 1 litre of freshly run water, leaving the kettle to cool for 30 minutes and no longer, and using the scoop provided to add one level scoop to every 30 ml of water. The record also warns not to press or heap the powder and not to use artificially softened or repeatedly boiled water.

Cow & Gate 1 preparation and safety points

  • Cow & Gate 1 First Infant Milk Formula from Birth 1.2kg (2x600g): Cow & Gate 1 comes as a 1.2 kg pack (2 x 600 g) and is made from a cow milk base. The record states powdered milks are not sterile and that failure to follow instructions may make your baby ill. The larger pack size may reduce how often you reorder, while the safety warning reminds you to follow the preparation steps exactly.
  • Cow & Gate 1 First Infant Milk Formula from Birth 1.2kg (2x600g): The preparation steps include boiling 1 litre of freshly run water, cooling for 30 minutes, and adding one level scoop to every 30 ml of water. The record says to shake immediately and vigorously for at least 10 seconds. These are specific, confirmed steps you can follow, unlike the goat milk records which give less detail on water volume and shaking time.

Side by side: goat milk vs cow milk first infant formula

Use this table to see the confirmed differences at a glance. Where a detail is not listed for a product, treat it as unconfirmed rather than absent.

  • Milk base: Nannycare and Kendamil use whole A2 goat milk. Cow & Gate uses a cow milk base.
  • Added fibres and fats: Nannycare lists 2'FL fibre and plant-based DHA. Kendamil lists GOS and whole milk fats. Cow & Gate lists DHA but the record does not specify fibre types.
  • Free-from claims: Nannycare is free from palm oil, soya, GMOs, added whey and fish oil. Kendamil is free from palm oil, fish oil, soya and maltodextrin. Cow & Gate is palm oil free.
  • Pack size: Nannycare and Kendamil are 800 g tins. Cow & Gate is a 1.2 kg pack (2 x 600 g).
  • Preparation detail in record: Nannycare gives a scoop size of 4.3 g and says to add one level scoop to every 30 ml of water. Cow & Gate gives full steps including boiling 1 litre, cooling 30 minutes, and shaking for at least 10 seconds. Kendamil gives a scoop-to-water ratio but no further steps in the supplied record.

How to choose when your baby is newborn

For a newborn, both goat milk and cow milk first infant formulas are labelled suitable from birth to 6 months. The decision often comes down to ingredient preferences. If you want to avoid palm oil, soya and fish oil, the Nannycare and Kendamil goat milk records confirm those are absent. If you prefer a cow milk formula with a larger pack and detailed preparation steps, Cow & Gate 1 provides that.

Taste is another factor. Kendamil describes its goat milk formula as having a naturally mild and pleasant taste, while Nannycare describes a naturally creamy taste. These are manufacturer descriptions, not guarantees your baby will accept either. Offer a feed and watch for acceptance and tolerance.

Always follow the preparation instructions on the tin you buy. The records here show that preparation details vary between brands, so do not assume one brand's steps apply to another.

Practical checks before you buy

  • Check the age range on the tin: All three products are labelled for 0–6 months. Do not use a first infant formula beyond 6 months without healthcare guidance; Cow & Gate notes a move to Follow-On Milk at 6 months.
  • Confirm the scoop size: Nannycare lists a 4.3 g scoop included in the tin. Kendamil and Cow & Gate give a one-scoop-to-30-ml ratio but do not list the scoop weight in the supplied record. Use the scoop that comes with the tin.
  • Read the full preparation steps on the packaging: The Cow & Gate record includes a 30-minute cooling step and a 10-second shake. The goat milk records do not include those details, so rely on the tin for complete instructions.
  • Consider pack size against your usage: An 800 g tin suits those who want a smaller opening, while the 1.2 kg Cow & Gate pack may last longer. There is no confirmed feeding guide in these records, so you cannot calculate exact duration from the information here.