Quick answer

For most heavy chewers, the Anco Hairy Lamb Trotter is the longer-lasting choice thanks to its dense, high-protein texture, while the Pork Roll peanut butter braid offers a softer, more flavorful chew that won't last as long but is gentler on teeth.

Why texture and protein matter for chew duration

The key to a long-lasting chew is its density and protein content. The Anco Hairy Lamb Trotter boasts 57.7% protein and a firm, hairy texture that encourages extended gnawing. This makes it a robust option for dogs that like to work at their treats.

In contrast, the Pork Roll peanut butter braid is made from high-quality pork with a firm but softer texture. While it still promotes chewing, it tends to be consumed faster than a dense trotter, especially by aggressive chewers.

Natural ingredients and dental benefits

Both chews are natural and free from artificial additives, making them safe choices for daily chewing. The lamb trotter's hair acts as a natural dewormer, an added benefit you won't get from the pork braid.

The Pork Roll's firm texture helps reduce plaque and tartar, supporting dental health. However, if your priority is maximum chew time, the trotter's density gives it an edge.

Trade-offs to consider

  • Chew duration: The Anco Hairy Lamb Trotter is denser and higher in protein, so it lasts longer for most dogs. The Pork Roll peanut butter braid is softer and will be finished sooner. If your dog is a power chewer, lean toward the trotter.
  • Dental benefits: The Pork Roll's firm texture helps reduce plaque and tartar. The lamb trotter also provides chewing action but its primary extra benefit is the natural deworming from the hair. Choose the braid if dental care is your main goal.
  • Flavor and gentleness: The Pork Roll is packed with pork flavor and is softer, making it more appealing to picky or senior dogs. The trotter is more intense and may be too tough for dogs with sensitive teeth. Offer the braid to dogs with dental sensitivities.

Product facts at a glance

  • Anco Hairy Lamb Trotter: Anco Hairy Lamb Trotter is 100% lamb with 57.7% protein and no artificial additives, and its hair works as a natural dewormer. The high protein and dense texture make it a long-lasting chew that also offers a natural deworming benefit.

    Anco Hairy Lamb Trotter

    Anco Hairy Lamb Trotter

  • Pork Roll: Pork Roll is a natural, long-lasting chew made from high-quality pork with a firm texture that encourages longer chewing and helps reduce plaque and tartar. It's a flavorful, softer alternative that supports dental health but may not last as long as a dense lamb trotter for heavy chewers.

    Pork Roll

    Pork Roll

Which chew fits your dog?

Best for

  • Dogs that love to gnaw for extended periods and need a long-lasting natural chew
  • Owners who want a single-ingredient treat with added deworming benefits

Not for

  • Dogs with dental issues or those that prefer a softer, more flavorful chew