Quick answer
Choose Maple Pumpkin if you want a cozy fall scent that smells like a pumpkin patch; choose Hollyday Spice if you prefer a warm, traditional holiday blend that evokes apple cider and simpler times. Both are limited-time Poo~Pourri sprays, so pick based on the season you're decorating for and whether you want a single-note pumpkin vibe or a spiced holiday mix.
Scent mood and season: pumpkin patch vs holiday spice
Maple Pumpkin leans into autumn: the catalog describes it as a seasonal classic that leaves the toilet smelling like you just picked a pumpkin from the patch. That makes it a natural fit for fall bathroom scent ideas, Thanksgiving hosting, or any space where you want a warm, gourmet feel.
Hollyday Spice is built for the holiday stretch. The catalog calls it a complex blend that reminds you of simpler times and may make you wonder if someone just made apple cider or dropped a yule log. If you want a holiday spice toilet spray that feels traditional rather than pumpkin-forward, this is the one.
Price and limited-time availability
At catalog prices, Hollyday Spice is listed at USD 6.99 (compared with USD 9.99), and Maple Pumpkin is listed at USD 7.09 (compared with USD 9.99). The difference is small, so let scent preference lead rather than trying to save a dime.
Both are limited-time scents, which means they may not be restocked once they sell out. If you find a favorite, consider buying a backup or picking up an extra as a seasonal scent gift idea before the season passes.
What both scents have in common
Both are Poo~Pourri toilet sprays that trap bathroom odor under the water's surface before it enters the air, and both are made with essential oils. The catalog also states a 100% odor-trapping guarantee for Maple Pumpkin; Hollyday Spice is described as a complex seasonal blend without a separate guarantee statement in the supplied facts.
Neither product page in the supplied facts lists specific size options beyond "Size," so check the available size selector on each product page if you need a particular bottle volume for a guest bath or gift.
Trade-offs to weigh before you choose
- Season timing: Maple Pumpkin fits fall and Thanksgiving; Hollyday Spice fits the holiday season from late November through December. If you're buying in early fall, Maple Pumpkin gives you more weeks of use; if you're shopping for December, Hollyday Spice is the more on-theme choice. Buy for the season you're actually in, not the one you're planning for.
- Scent profile: Maple Pumpkin is a single, recognizable pumpkin-patch scent; Hollyday Spice is a complex blend that mixes traditional holiday spice notes. Choose Maple Pumpkin if you want a straightforward fall gourmand; choose Hollyday Spice if you like layered, spiced scents. If you dislike pumpkin, skip Maple Pumpkin entirely.
- Price difference: Hollyday Spice is listed at USD 6.99 and Maple Pumpkin at USD 7.09, both against a USD 9.99 comparison price. The gap is only ten cents, so don't let it override scent preference. Decide on scent first; price is effectively a tie.
- Limited-time risk: Both are limited-time scents, so availability can end without notice. If you're buying for a gift or want to use one through the whole season, order early or add a backup bottle. Treat either scent as a seasonal purchase, not a permanent staple.
Product facts at a glance
-
Maple Pumpkin - Poo~Pourri Toilet Sprays: Limited-edition fall scent described as smelling like you just picked a pumpkin from the patch. Best if you want a cozy autumn atmosphere rather than a holiday-spice blend.
Maple Pumpkin - Poo~Pourri Toilet Sprays
Maple Pumpkin - Poo~Pourri Toilet Sprays
-
Hollyday Spice: Complex seasonal blend with traditional holiday-spice notes that evoke apple cider and simpler times. A strong pick for holiday hosting or anyone who prefers spice over pumpkin.
Hollyday Spice
Which scent is right for you?
Best for
- Fall hosts who want a pumpkin-patch scent for Thanksgiving and autumn bathrooms
- Shoppers looking for a cozy seasonal scent gift idea in September and October
- Anyone who prefers a straightforward gourmand fragrance over a spice blend
Not for
- Shoppers who want a holiday-specific scent for December events
- People who dislike pumpkin or gourmand fragrances
- Anyone who needs a year-round scent rather than a limited-time option