Quick answer
For most photographers, the choice comes down to a dedicated camera backpack (best for heavy gear and all-day carry) or a camera insert (best for using an everyday bag). We recommend starting with a purpose-built backpack like the Shimoda Action V2 X25 Women's Backpack if you shoot outdoors, or a modular insert like the Tenba BYOB 9 if you want to keep using your existing bag.
Dedicated backpack vs. camera insert: the core trade-off
A dedicated camera backpack offers built-in padding, custom dividers, and often a dedicated laptop compartment. It's the most convenient option when you're carrying a full kit and want to grab your camera quickly. The downside: you're stuck with one bag for both camera gear and personal items.
A camera insert like the Tenba BYOB 9 turns any bag into a camera bag. This gives you flexibility—use a hiking pack for a long trek, a stylish tote for the city, or a suitcase for air travel. The trade-off is that you need to pack and unpack the insert, and you lose some quick-access convenience.
Fit and comfort matter more than you think
A bag that doesn't fit your body can ruin a day of shooting. The Shimoda Action V2 X25 Women's Backpack is designed with a Women's Tech Strap and a shorter torso length, making it a great choice for women photographers who often find unisex packs too long or loose. If you're not the intended gender of that model, test the bag in person or look for an adjustable unisex alternative.
For inserts, fit is about the bag you're putting them into. Measure your bag's interior before buying—the Tenba BYOB 9 is compact and soft-shelled, so it molds to most shapes, but it won't protect gear in a bag that's too large or lacks structure.
Capacity and gear type: mirrorless vs. DSLR
Mirrorless cameras and compact DSLRs are smaller, so you don't need a massive bag. The Shimoda Action V2 X25 comes with a Small Mirrorless Core Unit, which fits a mirrorless body and a couple of lenses. If you shoot with a full-frame DSLR or long telephoto lenses, you'll need a larger core unit or a bigger bag.
The Tenba BYOB 9 is designed for mirrorless or compact DSLR cameras with 2-3 lenses. It's a good choice if your kit is small and you want to travel light. For larger gear, look at the BYOB 10 or 13 models.
How to decide: 3 rules
- Rule 1: Match the bag to your primary activity: If you hike, bike, or travel off the beaten path, choose a dedicated camera backpack with a harness system (e.g., Shimoda Action V2 X25). If you commute, fly often, or want to use your current bag, choose a camera insert (e.g., Tenba BYOB 9). Think about your most common carry scenario—not your dream trip.
- Rule 2: Check your gear size first: List your camera body and lenses. A mirrorless kit fits the Shimoda X25's Small Core Unit or the Tenba BYOB 9. A full-frame DSLR with a 70-200mm lens will not fit either—you'll need a larger core unit or a bigger insert. Don't guess. Measure your gear or check the manufacturer's fit guide.
- Rule 3: Test the fit before you commit: A dedicated backpack should sit comfortably on your hips and shoulders. If you're a woman, consider a women-specific model like the Shimoda Action V2 X25. For inserts, make sure your outer bag has enough structure to hold the insert securely. If you can't try in person, read reviews from people with a similar body type.
Featured products
-
Shimoda Action V2 X25 Women's Backpack Starter Kit Teal (with Small Mirrorless Core Unit): The Women's Action X25 is designed for female photographers looking for an agile, fast access and extra compact adventure camera bag with a Women's Tech Strap. This backpack is purpose-built for women, offering a better fit and more comfort during long hikes or active shoots.
Shimoda Action V2 X25 Women's Backpack Starter Kit Teal (with Small Mirrorless Core Unit)
-
Tenba BYOB 9 Camera Insert Black: The Tenba BYOB 9 fits a mirrorless or compact DSLR camera with 2-3 lenses and its soft shell molds easily to the shape of any carrying bag. You can turn any backpack, suitcase, or handbag into a camera bag, giving you flexibility without buying a dedicated camera bag.
Tenba BYOB 9 Camera Insert Black
Which option fits you best?
Best for
- Outdoor photographers who need a comfortable, weather-resistant backpack for hiking or adventure travel
- Photographers who want to use their existing everyday bag or suitcase for camera gear
Not for
- Photographers with a full-frame DSLR and large telephoto lenses (consider a larger dedicated backpack or a bigger insert)
