Quick answer
Start your Critical Role pin collection by picking a theme or character you love, then build gradually with enamel pins that suit your style and display them safely to keep them in top condition.
Choosing your first pin: character, faction, or symbol
Critical Role offers pins that celebrate specific characters (like the Chibi Pin No. 36 - Nydas Okiro), campaign factions (like the Campaign 4 United Faction Pin), or iconic logos (like the Candela Obscura Lapel Pin). Your first pin can be a personal favorite character or a symbol that represents a campaign you love. Each type has a different feel: character pins often have more detail and color, while faction or logo pins are usually more subtle and versatile for everyday wear.
Display and storage: keeping your pins safe
Enamel pins are durable but can scratch or bend if not stored properly. Avoid stacking them loose in a drawer or bag. Use a dedicated pin display board, a fabric banner, or a corkboard to show them off, or keep them in a soft pouch or pin binder if you prefer to store them away. For pins you wear, rotate them regularly to reduce stress on the clasp.
Steps to start your Critical Role pin collection
- Choose a focus for your collection: Decide whether you want to collect pins from a specific campaign (like Exandria Unlimited: Calamity or Campaign 4), character pins, or logo pins. This helps you avoid impulse buys and keeps your collection cohesive. A focused collection is easier to display and feels more intentional. Common mistake: buying every pin you see and ending up with a mismatched set.
- Pick your first pin: Start with one pin that excites you the most. For example, the Critical Role Chibi Pin No. 36 - Nydas Okiro if you love character art, or the Candela Obscura Lapel Pin if you prefer a sleek logo design. Check the size and back closure to make sure it fits your intended use. Your first pin sets the tone. Common mistake: choosing a pin that is too large or heavy for where you plan to wear it.
- Plan your display method: Before you have many pins, decide how you will display or store them. A small corkboard, a fabric banner, or a pin display case works well. If you plan to wear pins, consider a rotation system to avoid bending the clasp. Having a display plan prevents damage and makes your collection look great. Common mistake: storing pins loose in a drawer where they can get scratched.
- Care for your pins regularly: Wipe pins with a soft dry cloth to remove dust. Avoid exposing them to moisture or harsh chemicals. For pins with moving parts or delicate details, handle them gently and store them in a padded section. Regular care keeps your pins looking new. Common mistake: using water or cleaning solutions that can damage the enamel or metal finish.
- Expand your collection thoughtfully: Add new pins that complement your theme or fill a gap. Look for limited releases or campaign-specific pins that match your focus. The Campaign 4 United Faction Pin is a good example of a piece that ties a collection together. Slow growth leads to a more meaningful collection. Common mistake: buying duplicates or pins outside your theme just because they are on sale.
Pins featured in this guide
-
Critical Role Chibi Pin No. 36 - Nydas Okiro: Gold is meant to uplift the people, and this Nydas Okiro pin will add the Guildmaster's own shine to all he adorns. This chibi pin is a great choice if you want a character-focused piece with a playful, detailed design that stands out on a jacket or bag.
Critical Role Chibi Pin No. 36 - Nydas Okiro
-
Critical Role Campaign 4 United Faction Pin: This antique gold 3D molded metal pin bears the united faction symbol of Campaign 4 and can be worn two ways: fastened with a safety pin clasp or threaded through its hidden metal loop. The dual wearing option makes it versatile for both display and daily use, and the faction symbol is a subtle nod to the campaign that other fans will recognize.
Critical Role Campaign 4 United Faction Pin
-
Candela Obscura Lapel Pin: This subtle yet stylish pin is made of raised and recessed metal, embossed with the official logo, and has a safety-pin back closure. Its small size (0.75 inches) and understated design make it ideal for a lapel or collar, perfect for a more professional or low-key look.
