Quick Answer

For your first anal plug, choose a small, firm silicone model, use plenty of lubricant, and go slowly. Focus on relaxation and listen to your body at every step.

Why a small firm plug is a smart start

A small size reduces the stretch on your sphincter, making insertion more comfortable for beginners. Firm silicone provides steady pressure and is easier to control than softer materials, which can bend or fold during insertion.

Firm plugs also hold their shape well, so you can feel exactly where they are. This helps you learn your anatomy and build confidence before moving to larger or softer toys.

Choose the right lubricant

Silicone plugs need a water-based lubricant. Silicone-based lubes can degrade silicone toys, so avoid them. A thick water-based lube stays put longer and reduces friction during insertion.

Apply lube generously to both the plug and your anus. Reapply if you feel any resistance. There is no such thing as too much lube when you are starting out.

Step-by-step beginner routine

  1. Prepare and relax: Empty your bowels and take a warm shower. Relax your body with deep breaths. Tension makes insertion harder, so give yourself time to unwind. If you feel anxious, pause and breathe. Stress is the number one reason for discomfort.
  2. Lubricate generously: Apply a thick water-based lubricant to the plug and your anus. Start with a small amount, then add more if needed. Never use silicone-based lube with a silicone plug. Reapply lube if you feel any dragging or burning.
  3. Start with a finger: Gently insert a well-lubricated finger to warm up the sphincter. Move it slowly in small circles. This helps your muscles relax and prepares them for the plug. If a finger feels too tight, stop and breathe. Try again after a few minutes.
  4. Insert the plug slowly: Hold the base of the plug and press the tip against your anus. Apply steady, gentle pressure while exhaling. Do not force it. Let your muscles open around the plug. If you feel sharp pain, stop and remove. Pain is not normal.
  5. Wear and listen to your body: Start with 5-10 minutes. Move around to find a comfortable position. If you feel any discomfort, remove the plug. Build up wear time gradually over sessions. Set a timer for your first few sessions to avoid losing track of time.
  6. Remove with care: Relax and gently pull the plug out while bearing down slightly. Go slow. Clean the plug with warm water and mild soap or a dedicated toy cleaner after each use. Never pull out forcefully. If it feels stuck, relax and try later.

Product spotlight

  • Screw - Extra Small, Firm: The Screw – Extra Small, Firm features a spiraled shaft designed to work deep and tight, burrowing in with relentless precision. The spiral shape provides graduated stimulation while the small, firm profile makes it a manageable first plug for beginners.

    Screw - Extra Small, Firm

    Screw - Extra Small, Firm