Quick answer

Choose Supreme Keep It Clean Lavender if you want a lower upfront price and a lavender scent for bedding, cages, and carpets. Pick Johnsons Clean n Safe if you prefer a straightforward disinfectant spray for general pet areas and want to save compared with its list price.

Cleaning scope and surfaces

Supreme Keep It Clean is described as a cleaner, deodorant, and disinfectant that can be used on hutches, cages, bedding, carpets, and other housing areas. Johnsons Clean n Safe is also a disinfectant, cleaner, and deodorant, but its catalog description focuses on killing bacteria and viruses where your cat or dog live, sleep, and feed. In practice, both cover everyday pet messes, but Keep It Clean explicitly lists carpets and bedding, which may matter if you routinely treat soft surfaces.

Scent and sensitivity

Keep It Clean comes in a lavender scent, while Johnsons Clean n Safe does not specify a fragrance in the supplied facts. If you or your pet are sensitive to added fragrance, the unscented option may be safer, but check the label for any scent or added ingredients before use. Lavender can be pleasant for humans but may not suit every animal, so test in a small area first.

Price and value

At catalog prices, Keep It Clean is USD 2.72 for 500ml (compared with USD 4.19), and Johnsons Clean n Safe is USD 2.95 for 500ml (compared with USD 3.99). Keep It Clean has the lower current price and the larger discount, but both are close in cost per bottle. If you clean frequently, the lower price may add up, but the difference is small enough that scent and surface suitability should guide your choice.

Trade-offs to weigh

  • Price vs. scent: Keep It Clean costs less at the current catalog price and adds a lavender scent. Johnsons Clean n Safe costs slightly more and does not list a fragrance, which may suit scent-sensitive pets better. If fragrance is a concern, check the Johnsons label for scent before buying.
  • Surface flexibility: Keep It Clean explicitly lists carpets and bedding, while Johnsons focuses on areas where pets live, sleep, and feed. For carpets and soft furnishings, Keep It Clean gives clearer guidance. For carpet accidents, Keep It Clean is the more clearly specified option.
  • Disinfection confidence: Both are labeled as disinfectants, but Johnsons specifically mentions killing bacteria and viruses. If disinfection is your main goal, Johnsons states that benefit directly. Choose Johnsons if you want a stated pathogen-killing claim.

Product facts

Which spray fits your routine?

Best for

  • Homes with carpets and pet bedding that need regular cleaning and deodorizing
  • Owners who prefer a lavender scent and a lower upfront price

Not for

  • Pets or people sensitive to added fragrance
  • Spaces where you need a specific unscented disinfectant