Quick answer

Choose Keiko the Edamame if you want a textured, veggie-shaped teether that doubles as a sensory and bath toy at a lower price. Choose the Pink Cell teether if you prefer a limited-edition, hand-painted natural rubber piece with a soft, easy-grasp shape. Both are safe to chew and hang from a strap; the trade-off is price and collectibility versus everyday versatility.

Material and texture: what your baby actually chews

Keiko the Edamame is built around realistic textures that stimulate gums and senses, and it works for teething, bath time, and sensory play. The Pink Cell teether is handcrafted from 100% natural rubber from Hevea trees and hand painted with natural pigments, with a soft, easy-to-grasp shape that soothes gums during sensory, teething, and bath play. If your baby prefers varied bumps and ridges, Keiko offers more surface variety. If your baby likes a softer, smoother chew, Pink Cell is the gentler option.

Price, edition, and long-term value

At catalog prices, Keiko the Edamame is the more affordable everyday pick, while the Pink Cell teether costs more because it is a limited edition, hand-painted piece. That price gap reflects collectibility and handcrafting, not a safety difference. If you want a teether that can be replaced easily or used in the bath without worry, Keiko is the practical choice. If you are buying a keepsake or a design-forward gift, the Pink Cell edition justifies its higher price.

Portability and daily use

Both teethers are designed to hang from a strap, so either can go on the stroller or diaper bag. Keiko's veggie shape and texture make it a natural fit for on-the-go chewing and sensory play, while Pink Cell's soft rubber and graspable form suit babies who are still learning to hold and bring toys to their mouth. If you need one teether that covers chewing, bath, and sensory play with minimal fuss, Keiko is the simpler all-rounder. If you want a softer, collectible piece for home and gentle outings, Pink Cell fits that role.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Texture variety vs. softness: Keiko the Edamame uses realistic textures for sensory stimulation and gum relief, while Pink Cell is soft and easy to grasp with a smoother chew. Pick Keiko for texture-seeking babies; pick Pink Cell for babies who prefer a softer mouthfeel.
  • Everyday price vs. limited edition: Keiko is the lower-priced everyday option; Pink Cell is a limited edition hand-painted piece that costs more. Choose Keiko for value and replaceability, Pink Cell for collectibility or gifting.
  • All-rounder vs. keepsake: Keiko is designed for teething, bath, and sensory play as a single versatile toy; Pink Cell is handcrafted natural rubber intended for sensory, teething, and bath play as a design-led object. If you want one toy to do everything, Keiko is simpler; if you want a keepsake, Pink Cell is the pick.

Product facts

  • Keiko the Edamame Baby Teether: Keiko the Edamame is a chewable baby toy for teething, bath time, and sensory play with realistic textures that stimulate senses and relieve teething gums. One toy covers chewing, bath, and sensory play, so you pack less and clean fewer items.
  • Baby Teether Pink Cell: Oli&Carol x Peter Halley Pink Cell is a limited edition natural rubber and educational toy for sensory, teething, and bath time play, handcrafted in natural rubber and hand painted with natural pigments. The limited edition and hand-painted finish make it a collectible or gift piece rather than a replaceable everyday teether.

Which teether fits your baby?

Best for

  • Babies who like varied textures and need gum relief during teething and bath time
  • Parents who want a lower-priced, versatile teether that can hang from a strap for on-the-go use
  • Sensory play and healthy-lifestyle introductions with a veggie-shaped toy

Not for

  • Shoppers looking for a limited-edition or collectible design piece
  • Babies who prefer a softer, smoother chew than textured surfaces
  • Gift buyers who want a hand-painted natural rubber keepsake