Choosing Between Lamb and Salmon in Grain-Free Wet Food

Both Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Lamb in Gravy and Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream with Salmon in Gravy are grain-free wet dog foods that provide high-quality protein and moisture. The main difference comes down to the protein source—lamb versus salmon—and how each might suit your dog's taste, digestion, or dietary needs.

Below we compare their ingredients, texture, and best uses so you can decide which 13.2 oz can fits your dog's bowl.

Key Product Facts at a Glance

  • Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Lamb in Gravy Grain Free Wet Dog Food 13.2 oz: Real lamb is the first ingredient, providing a rich source of protein to support strong muscles and overall health. The grain-free formula includes sweet potatoes and peas for natural fiber and energy. Lamb is a novel protein for many dogs, making this a good option for those with food sensitivities or dogs that need a break from chicken or beef.

    Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Lamb in Gravy Grain Free Wet Dog Food 13.2 oz

    Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Lamb in Gravy Grain Free Wet Dog Food 13.2 oz

  • Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream with Salmon in Gravy Grain Free Wet Dog Food 13.2 oz: Real salmon and ocean fish are the primary protein sources, described as highly digestible. The savory gravy adds moisture to help keep dogs hydrated. Salmon is rich in omega-3 fatty acids and is often well-tolerated by dogs with sensitive stomachs. The extra moisture can be beneficial for dogs that don't drink enough water.

    Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream with Salmon in Gravy Grain Free Wet Dog Food 13.2 oz

    Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream with Salmon in Gravy Grain Free Wet Dog Food 13.2 oz

Lamb vs Salmon: What to Consider

Both recipes are grain-free, contain no artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives, and are suitable for all breeds and life stages. Their smooth, palatable texture makes them ideal for picky eaters, senior dogs, or as a topper to enhance dry kibble.

  • Protein Source and Novelty: Sierra Mountain Lamb uses lamb as the first ingredient—a less common protein that can be helpful for dogs with food allergies or those who need a novel protein. Pacific Stream Salmon relies on salmon and ocean fish, which are also highly digestible and provide natural omega-3s.
  • Texture and Moisture: Both are described as having a smooth, palatable texture with gravy. Pacific Stream Salmon's savory gravy is specifically noted for helping with hydration, which may be a plus for dogs that don't drink enough water or for warmer months.
  • Best Use Cases: Sierra Mountain Lamb works well as a complete meal for dogs that prefer lamb or need a novel protein. Pacific Stream Salmon is excellent for fish-loving dogs or as a hydrating topper. Both can be served alone or mixed with dry food.

Honest Trade-Offs

Neither recipe includes grains, but both contain potatoes and pea-based ingredients. If your dog has a known sensitivity to legumes or potatoes, check the full ingredient list. The lamb variety may be harder to find in some stores compared to more common fish or poultry flavors. The salmon option costs slightly more per can ($2.15 vs $1.97), though both are priced below their catalog comparison prices.

Since the supplied information does not include guaranteed analysis or calorie counts, compare these foods based on protein source and ingredient philosophy rather than exact nutritional percentages.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Lamb if your dog needs a novel protein source, has a sensitive stomach, or you want to rotate proteins away from common meats. Go with Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Salmon if your dog loves fish, you want extra moisture in their diet, or you prefer a highly digestible protein that's rich in omega-3s.

Both are grain-free, high-protein wet foods that can be fed as a complete meal or used as a topper. Your dog's preference and any known food sensitivities will be the deciding factors.