Quick answer

Choose the Lavender carton refill if you want a calming scent and the lowest upfront price; choose Citrus Vanilla if you prefer a bright, citrusy aroma and don't mind paying a little more for it. Both are tear-free 2-in-1 formulas that work for kids and adults, and both refill cartons cut plastic waste compared with buying multiple bottles.

Scent is the biggest difference

The formulas are otherwise the same gentle shampoo + body wash, so the real decision comes down to fragrance. Lavender is a classic calming scent, while Citrus Vanilla blends bright citrus with warm vanilla. Both are made with naturally derived botanicals and essential oils, but scent preference is personal—what soothes one child may be too strong or too faint for another.

Price and value: Lavender costs less per carton

At the catalog price, the Lavender refill carton is $17.35, while the Citrus Vanilla carton is $20.43. Both are 32-oz cartons, so the Lavender option gives you more product for your money. However, the Citrus Vanilla carton also lists a higher comparison price ($27.99), so the discount is deeper in percentage terms. If budget is your top priority, Lavender wins; if you love the scent, the extra cost may be worth it.

Eco-friendly refills reduce plastic

Both cartons are designed to refill your empty Honest Shampoo + Body Wash bottles. According to Honest, each refill carton uses 89% less plastic than three 10-oz bottles. That means either scent helps you cut down on single-use plastic, which is a win for families trying to be more eco-conscious. The trade-off is that you need to keep and reuse your bottles, which takes a little planning.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Scent: Lavender is calming and floral; Citrus Vanilla is bright and sweet. Both are gentle and tear-free, but scent is subjective—consider whether your child prefers a soothing or energizing aroma. If you're unsure, start with a smaller size to test the scent before committing to a refill carton.
  • Price per carton: Lavender costs $17.35, Citrus Vanilla costs $20.43. Both are 32-oz cartons, so Lavender gives you more product for your money. Set a budget per ounce if you're comparing value across scents.
  • Plastic savings: Both cartons use 89% less plastic than three 10-oz bottles. The eco benefit is the same regardless of scent. Choose either refill to reduce waste, but remember you'll need to reuse your bottles.

Product facts

Which refill is right for your family?

Best for

  • Families who prefer a calming, lavender scent for bedtime baths
  • Budget-conscious shoppers who want the lowest price per carton
  • Anyone looking to reduce plastic waste with a refill system

Not for

  • Those who dislike floral or herbal scents
  • People who prefer a bright, citrusy fragrance
  • Shoppers who don't want to reuse bottles and prefer ready-to-use bottles