Quick answer

Choose Lip Balm #4 if you want the lower upfront price and the same five-scent lineup. Choose Lip Balm #3 if you prefer the slightly higher-priced option but still want the same short, nourishing ingredient list.

The real difference is price, not performance

Both Lip Balm #3 and Lip Balm #4 come from the same natural lip balm line, with five scent options and a formula built on only a few nourishing ingredients. The catalog facts do not list separate formulas or scent strengths for each product, so you should not expect one to outperform the other in feel or longevity based on the information available.

That makes the decision straightforward: pick based on the price you want to pay and the scent you prefer, not on a promised difference in moisturizing power. If you are replacing a balm that stopped working, either option can serve as a simple everyday lip moisturizer.

When the higher price might still make sense

Lip Balm #3 is listed at USD 4.26 against a USD 6.00 comparison price, while Lip Balm #4 is USD 3.60 against the same comparison price. The gap is small, but it matters if you are buying multiple balms or restocking often.

There is no supplied fact showing that Lip Balm #3 includes extra ingredients, a larger size, or a different finish. If you are choosing between the two, treat the price difference as the main trade-off rather than assuming the more expensive balm is more effective.

Trade-offs to weigh before you buy

  • Price per balm: Lip Balm #4 costs less upfront than Lip Balm #3. If you want to keep a balm in several rooms or bags, the lower price adds up. Set a budget per balm before choosing a scent.
  • Scent choice: Both products offer five scents, but the catalog does not specify which scents overlap. Check the available scent options on each product page before you commit to a favorite. Confirm the exact scent name is in stock for the product you choose.
  • Ingredient expectations: Both are described as containing only a few nourishing ingredients. Neither product page in the supplied facts lists a full ingredient breakdown, so if you have a sensitivity, review the complete label before use. Patch-test a new balm if your lips react easily.

Product facts at a glance

  • Lip Balm #3: Lip Balm #3 is priced at USD 4.26, with a catalog comparison price of USD 6.00. You pay a little more per balm than Lip Balm #4, but the listed comparison price shows the discount is still meaningful.

    Lip Balm #3

    Lip Balm #3

  • Lip Balm #4: Lip Balm #4 is priced at USD 3.60, with a catalog comparison price of USD 6.00. This is the lower-priced way to get the same five-scent natural lip balm lineup, which helps if you buy several at once.

    Lip Balm #4

    Lip Balm #4

Which lip balm fits you?

Best for

  • Shoppers who want the lowest price for a natural lip balm with five scent options
  • Anyone buying multiple balms to stash in a bag, desk, or car

Not for

  • Shoppers who need a full ingredient list before purchasing, since neither product page supplies one here
  • Anyone looking for a tinted, medicated, or exfoliating lip product, which these are not described as