Quick Answer
If you already own a pump bottle, buying a liquid hand soap refill saves more upfront and reduces plastic waste. If you're starting fresh or want a backup bottle, the set offers better value per ounce.
Why the Refill Wins on Cost Per Ounce
When you compare the catalog prices, the refill is the clear winner on a per-ounce basis. The Compassion Flower Liquid Hand Soap Refill costs USD 5.41, while the Iowa Pine Liquid Hand Soap & Refill Set costs USD 8.96. Since the set includes a full pump bottle plus a refill, you're paying more upfront, but the refill alone delivers the same amount of soap for less.
The Set's Hidden Value: Convenience and Backup
The set is more than just soap—it comes with a reusable pump bottle. That means you can keep one bottle in the kitchen and one in the bathroom, or have a backup ready when the first runs out. If you're new to Mrs. Meyer's or want to try a scent without committing to a large refill, the set gives you a complete start.
A Trade-Off: Scent Choice and Program Support
Your choice also depends on which scent you prefer. The Iowa Pine set has a festive, tree-inspired scent with clove and cedar, while the Compassion Flower refill supports the Lots of Compassion program with a $1 donation per product sold during a limited time. If you care about that cause, the refill offers a way to save money and give back.
How to Decide: Refill or Set?
- Choose the refill if:: You already have a pump bottle from Mrs. Meyer's or another brand that fits. You'll pay less per ounce and create less packaging waste. Check that your existing pump bottle is clean and compatible before buying a refill.
- Choose the set if:: You're new to Mrs. Meyer's, want a matching bottle for a gift, or need a spare for another sink. You'll pay more upfront but get a complete unit. Consider whether you'll actually use the extra bottle—otherwise the refill is more economical.
- Compare by cost per ounce:: Divide the catalog price by the fluid ounces to see which option gives you more soap for your money. The refill typically wins, but the set may be worth the premium for the bottle. Do the math for the specific scents you want, since prices can vary by product.
Product Facts
-
Iowa Pine Liquid Hand Soap & Refill Set: The Iowa Pine Liquid Hand Soap & Refill Set costs USD 8.96 and includes a full pump bottle plus a refill, with a scent of clove and cedar. You get a reusable bottle and a backup refill, so you're ready to go from day one without buying extra packaging.
Iowa Pine Liquid Hand Soap & Refill Set
-
Compassion Flower Liquid Hand Soap Refill: The Compassion Flower Liquid Hand Soap Refill costs USD 5.41 and is a non-drying formula with essential oils, aloe vera, and olive oil. It's the lower-cost way to keep your existing pump bottle filled, and it supports the Lots of Compassion program with a $1 donation per product.
Compassion Flower Liquid Hand Soap Refill
Who Should Buy What
Best For
- Budget-conscious shoppers who already own a pump bottle and want to save money
- Eco-minded users who want to reduce plastic waste by reusing a bottle
Not For
- First-time buyers who need a complete setup or want to give a gift
- Anyone who prefers the festive Iowa Pine scent and wants a ready-to-use bottle