Two Llamas de Hickory caps, two ways to get the fit
The Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty fitted cap and the 39Thirty stretch fit cap share the same Copa de la Diversión logo, but they solve the fit question differently. The 59Fifty uses numbered sizes and a structured, high-crown build with a flat bill you can curve. The 39Thirty uses stretch sizes (S/M, M/L, L/XL) and a mid-crown, curved-bill profile. Your choice comes down to whether you want a precise, traditional fitted look or a more forgiving stretch fit.
Fitted vs stretch: the core differences
- Sizing system: 59Fifty: fitted sizes from 7 to 8 in eighths. 39Thirty: stretch sizes Small/Medium, Medium/Large, Large/X-Large.
- Crown and structure: 59Fifty: high crown, structured fit. 39Thirty: mid crown, structured fit.
- Bill: 59Fifty: flat bill with ability to curve. 39Thirty: curved bill.
- Material: 59Fifty: 100% performance polyester. 39Thirty: 95% polyester / 5% spandex.
- Care: 39Thirty record specifies wipe clean with a damp cloth. 59Fifty record does not include care instructions.
What the 59Fifty record confirms
-
Hickory Crawdads 2025 New Era Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty Fitted Cap: Fitted sizes available: 7, 7 1/8, 7 1/4, 7 3/8, 7 1/2, 7 5/8, 7 3/4, 8. You need to know your head size in inches or match a previous fitted cap; there is no stretch to compensate.
Hickory Crawdads 2025 New Era Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty Fitted Cap
-
Hickory Crawdads 2025 New Era Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty Fitted Cap: High crown, structured fit, flat bill with ability to curve. This is the classic on-field look; the flat bill can be curved to your preference.
-
Hickory Crawdads 2025 New Era Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty Fitted Cap: Material: 100% performance polyester. A single-material build that may feel different from the stretch blend of the 39Thirty.
-
Hickory Crawdads 2025 New Era Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty Fitted Cap: Officially licensed product. Confirms authenticity for collectors and fans.
What the 39Thirty record confirms
-
Hickory Crawdads New Era Llamas de Hickory 39Thirty Stretch Fit Cap: Stretch fit sizes: Small/Medium, Medium/Large, Large/X-Large. Three broad sizes instead of precise numbered sizes; the spandex blend provides stretch.
Hickory Crawdads New Era Llamas de Hickory 39Thirty Stretch Fit Cap
-
Hickory Crawdads New Era Llamas de Hickory 39Thirty Stretch Fit Cap: Mid crown, structured fit, curved bill. A lower profile than the 59Fifty and a ready-curved bill.
-
Hickory Crawdads New Era Llamas de Hickory 39Thirty Stretch Fit Cap: Material: 95% polyester / 5% spandex. The spandex content is what allows the cap to stretch over your head.
-
Hickory Crawdads New Era Llamas de Hickory 39Thirty Stretch Fit Cap: Wipe clean with a damp cloth; officially licensed product. Simple care guidance and authenticity confirmation.
How to choose your size without trying it on
For the 59Fifty, start with a fitted cap you already own and check the size label, or measure your head circumference and compare to a New Era size chart. Because the 59Fifty is structured and non-stretch, the fit is less forgiving. For the 39Thirty, the stretch sizes cover a range; if you are between sizes, the spandex blend may accommodate you, but the record does not specify the exact head circumference range for each size. If you are unsure, the 39Thirty is generally the lower-risk choice for a first Llamas de Hickory cap.
Care and longevity: what each record says
The 39Thirty record explicitly states to wipe clean with a damp cloth. The 59Fifty record does not include care instructions, so avoid assuming the same method applies; check the cap's interior label when it arrives. Both are officially licensed, and both feature raised embroidery, which can snag if washed aggressively. Spot cleaning is the safest approach for either cap, but only the 39Thirty has that instruction confirmed in the supplied information.
Which Llamas de Hickory cap should you pick?
Choose the 59Fifty if you know your fitted size, prefer a high-crown structured look, and want the option of a flat or curved bill. Choose the 39Thirty if you want a simpler size selection, a mid-crown profile with a pre-curved bill, and the reassurance of a stretch blend. Both carry the same Llamas de Hickory identity, so the decision is about fit and feel rather than the logo.

