Quick answer

Choose the S.T. Dupont La Nuit Montecristo Cigar Case if you need to carry up to three cigars near 56 ring gauge and want a hand-lacquered finish. Choose the Lubinski F-11028 Cigar Case if you prefer a zippered rectangular design with textured black exterior and blue edge trim at a lower price.

Capacity and ring gauge: what fits

The S.T. Dupont La Nuit is explicitly built to hold up to three cigars close to 56 ring gauge. That capacity suits smokers who regularly carry a few large-ring cigars. The Lubinski F-11028 does not list a capacity or maximum ring gauge in the catalog, so you cannot confirm from the specs alone whether it will fit your preferred vitola. If you often carry 56-ring cigars, the Dupont's stated limit removes the guesswork. For the Lubinski, check the internal dimensions or test with your cigars before relying on it for a full day out.

Materials and construction: lacquer vs textured exterior

The Dupont case uses a sliding metal and leather construction with a hand-lacquered finish that shifts from yellow to deep night blue. That design is as much about visual appeal as function; the lacquer finish is a signature element you won't find on typical leather cases. The Lubinski uses a textured black exterior with rounded corners and a gold-toned emblem, and its zippered rectangular form is a more conventional travel case shape. Neither case lists leather type or lining details, so if material specifics matter to you, ask before buying. In practice, the Dupont's sliding mechanism offers quick access, while the Lubinski's zipper keeps contents enclosed.

Price and value: what you pay for

At catalog prices, the Lubinski F-11028 is USD 132.00 (compared to a USD 200.00 reference), and the Dupont La Nuit is USD 315.00 (compared to USD 500.00). The Dupont costs more than twice as much. That premium buys the hand-lacquered finish, French craftsmanship, and the stated three-cigar capacity near 56 ring gauge. The Lubinski offers a zippered, branded case at a lower entry point, but without published capacity specs. If you need a case for two cigars, both could work, but only the Dupont confirms it holds up to three. For budget-conscious buyers who don't need the lacquer finish, the Lubinski is the practical pick.

Trade-offs to weigh

  • Capacity certainty vs flexibility: The Dupont states it holds up to three cigars near 56 ring gauge; the Lubinski does not list capacity or ring gauge. If you carry large cigars, the Dupont removes doubt. If you carry fewer or smaller cigars, the Lubinski may suffice, but verify fit first. Measure your cigars' ring gauge before choosing if you regularly smoke 50+ ring cigars.
  • Finish and construction: The Dupont's hand-lacquered finish and sliding metal/leather build are designed to be a showpiece; the Lubinski's textured exterior and zipper are more utilitarian. Neither is inherently better, but the Dupont demands more care to avoid scratches on the lacquer. Consider how you'll store the case—if it shares a pocket with keys, the Lubinski's textured finish may hide wear better.
  • Price vs features: The Dupont costs USD 315.00 versus USD 132.00 for the Lubinski. The extra money goes toward the lacquer finish, French craftsmanship, and confirmed capacity. The Lubinski offers a branded, zippered case at a lower price but with fewer published specs. Set a budget first; if you're under USD 200, the Lubinski is the only option here.

Product facts

  • S.T. Dupont La Nuit Montecristo Cigar Case: Hand-lacquered finish shifting from yellow to deep night blue; holds up to three cigars close to 56 ring gauge. You get a distinctive look and a confirmed capacity for large-ring cigars, so you can pack without guessing.

    S.T. Dupont La Nuit Montecristo Cigar Case

    S.T. Dupont La Nuit Montecristo Cigar Case

  • Lubinski F-11028 Cigar Case: Zippered rectangular design with textured black exterior, blue edge trim, rounded corners, and gold-toned Lubinski emblem. The zipper and rounded corners make it a straightforward, protective case for everyday carry, though capacity is not specified.

    Lubinski F-11028 Cigar Case

    Lubinski F-11028 Cigar Case

Which case fits your needs?

Best for

  • Smokers who regularly carry up to three cigars near 56 ring gauge and want a distinctive lacquered finish.
  • Buyers willing to pay a premium for French craftsmanship and a sliding metal/leather mechanism.

Not for

  • Budget-conscious buyers who don't need a lacquer finish or confirmed large-ring capacity.
  • Anyone who prefers a zippered closure and a more understated, textured exterior.