Quick answer
Choose the Lucy Curious Dark Harbor 7" figure if you want a character-driven, Kathie Olivas collectible with a lower entry price and a detailed sculpt. Choose the MONOLITH Dunny 8" Onyx Edition if you want a larger, limited-to-300 statement piece with a border-culture narrative. Neither is objectively better—your display space, budget, and attachment to the artist's story should decide.
Size and shelf presence: 7 vs 8 inches
The Lucy Curious Dark Harbor figure stands 7 inches tall, while the MONOLITH Dunny is 8 inches. That extra inch on the Dunny gives it a slightly more commanding silhouette, especially on a top shelf or in a cabinet where height draws the eye. The Lucy Curious figure, by contrast, is easier to fit into tighter spaces like a desk corner or a crowded bookshelf. Both are vinyl art figures, but the Dunny's form factor is the classic Dunny shape, which some collectors prefer for uniformity with other Dunnys. Lucy Curious has a more organic, character-based sculpt that stands apart from the Dunny silhouette.
Edition size and collectibility
The MONOLITH Dunny Onyx Edition is explicitly limited to 300 pieces worldwide, making it a scarcer find. The Lucy Curious Dark Harbor figure does not list a fixed edition size in the catalog information, though it is part of the Dark Harbor collection and comes in two colorways. If edition number matters to you, the MONOLITH's 300-piece run is a clear advantage. But scarcity is not the only driver of long-term satisfaction—if you connect more with Kathie Olivas's aesthetic, the Lucy Curious figure may hold more personal value regardless of edition size.
Price and value
At catalog prices, the Lucy Curious Dark Harbor figure is USD 58.39 (compared to a USD 79.99 list price), while the MONOLITH Dunny Onyx Edition is USD 98.99 (compared to USD 149.99). The Lucy Curious figure is the more affordable entry point, especially if you are new to collecting art figures. The MONOLITH Dunny costs more but offers a larger size and a hard edition number. Consider whether you are paying for scale and scarcity or for character design—both are valid reasons to choose one over the other.
Artist and narrative
Lucy Curious is a collaboration between Kidrobot, Kathie Olivas, and Brandt Peters, and it serves as the cornerstone of the Dark Harbor collection. Olivas is known for her eerie yet endearing characters, and this piece fits that mold. The MONOLITH Dunny is designed by ROBOT SODA (Juan Carlos Arenas), whose work draws on the bold, colorful, and rhythmic world of border culture. Arenas has said that growing up on the US-Mexico border immersed him in a mix of U.S. pop culture and tradition, which is central to his art. If you prefer a dark, whimsical narrative, Lucy Curious delivers. If you want a design that celebrates border culture with a modern iconic vignette, the MONOLITH Dunny is the one.
Trade-offs to weigh
- Edition size vs. personal connection: MONOLITH Dunny is limited to 300, which may drive future demand, but Lucy Curious offers a character-driven design by Kathie Olivas that some collectors find more emotionally resonant. If resale potential matters, lean MONOLITH; if personal enjoyment matters more, lean Lucy Curious.
- Price vs. scale: Lucy Curious is USD 58.39 and 7 inches tall; MONOLITH is USD 98.99 and 8 inches tall. The extra inch and limited run cost about USD 40 more. Decide whether the larger size and edition number justify the price difference for your budget.
- Display flexibility vs. statement presence: Lucy Curious's 7-inch frame fits tighter spaces, while MONOLITH's 8-inch Dunny shape makes a bolder, more uniform addition to a Dunny-focused shelf. Measure your intended display spot before choosing—both are vinyl, but the Dunny silhouette is more standardized.
Product facts
- Lucy Curious Dark Harbor 7" Vinyl Art Figure by Kathie Olivas: 7-inch tall vinyl art figure, cornerstone of the Dark Harbor collection, available in two colorways including this OG edition. A moderate size that fits most shelves and a lower price point make it a strong first limited art figure.
- MONOLITH Dunny 8" Vinyl Art Figure by ROBOT SODA - Onyx Edition (Limited to 300): 8-inch Dunny art figure by ROBOT SODA, limited to 300 pieces in the Onyx Edition, inspired by border culture. The explicit edition size and larger scale appeal to collectors who value scarcity and a bold statement piece.
Which should you choose?
Best for
- Collectors who prefer character-driven art and a lower entry price
- Fans of Kathie Olivas and the Dark Harbor collection
- Smaller display spaces or desks
Not for
- Collectors who prioritize a hard edition number and larger scale
- Fans of ROBOT SODA or border-culture-inspired design
- Those with a budget under USD 60
