Two toys, two different kinds of play

The Mad Cat Burrito Kicker and the Mad Cat Elfin Around Wand look like they belong in the same toy basket, but they ask your cat to do different things. The Burrito Kicker is a plush your cat grabs, kicks, and wrestles on its own. The Elfin Around Wand is a wand toy you move while your cat chases and bats. If you are choosing between them, the real question is not which is better. It is which kind of play your cat actually needs right now.

Side by side: what each toy is built for

  • Play style: The Burrito Kicker is a plush filled with catnip and silvervine, made for kicking, pouncing, and wrestling. The Elfin Around Wand is a wand-style toy for interactive chasing and batting during playtime.
  • Who starts the play: The kicker works when your cat chooses to engage with it. The wand toy depends on you moving it, so it is a shared activity rather than a solo one.
  • Scent attractants: The Burrito Kicker is filled with a custom blend of catnip and silvervine described as maximum potency, pure, and pesticide-free. The supplied information for the Elfin Around Wand does not list catnip or silvervine.
  • Sound: The Burrito Kicker's plush includes a crinkle sound. The supplied information for the Elfin Around Wand does not mention a sound element.
  • Size and color: Both come in one size and assorted colors. The Burrito Kicker's length is stated in the catalog as 10". No measurement is supplied for the Elfin Around Wand.

What the Burrito Kicker brings to a solo play session

  • Mad Cat Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy: Filled with a custom blend of catnip and silvervine described as maximum potency, pure, and pesticide-free. This is the core reason a cat might engage with the toy without you. The scent blend is the attractant that draws the cat in.

    Mad Cat Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy

    Mad Cat Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy

  • Mad Cat Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy: The plush includes a crinkle sound. Crinkle adds a sound cue while your cat kicks and wrestles, which can keep a solo session going longer than scent alone.

  • Mad Cat Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy: The catalog describes the burrito as 10" long. That length tells you roughly how much toy your cat has to grab and kick. It is a plush meant to be held between the front paws, not a small bat-around toy.

What the Elfin Around Wand asks of you

Which cat toy type fits your cat

Use these questions to decide, rather than picking the toy that looks more fun to you.

  • Does your cat play alone during the day?: The Burrito Kicker is the better fit. It is a plush your cat can kick and wrestle without you holding anything.
  • Does your cat need more movement?: The Elfin Around Wand is the toy built for chasing and batting. You control the pace and direction, so the activity level depends on how you move it.
  • Has your cat ignored catnip before?: The Burrito Kicker relies on a catnip and silvervine blend. The wand does not depend on scent at all, so it is the safer choice if scent-based toys have not worked.
  • Do you want a toy that makes noise?: The Burrito Kicker has a crinkle element. The Elfin Around Wand has no sound feature listed in the supplied information.
  • Are you choosing for a multi-cat home?: A wand toy is easier to run for one cat at a time. A kicker can be shared, but the catalog does not provide guidance on multi-cat use, so supervise and separate cats if play gets rough.

What the product information does not tell you

Neither product record includes care instructions, safety warnings, or durability claims. That is a gap in the supplied information, not a statement that the toys are unsafe or hard to clean. Before you buy, check the packaging for washing guidance and inspect both toys for loose pieces or tears as your cat plays.

The records also do not state an age range or a weight limit. If you have a kitten or a very strong chewer, use your judgment and supervise play. For the wand, keep the string and any small parts away from a cat that tends to swallow toys.

Finally, the Burrito Kicker's 10" length is the only measurement supplied. The Elfin Around Wand has no listed length, so you cannot compare reach or size from the catalog alone.

The practical answer

If you want a toy your cat can use without you, choose the Mad Cat Burrito Kicker. Its catnip and silvervine fill and crinkle sound are designed for solo kicking and wrestling. If you want to actively play with your cat and encourage chasing, choose the Mad Cat Elfin Around Wand. Many cats do well with both, because they cover different needs: one for self-directed play, one for time with you.