Start With Your Filter Body, Not the Sponge

Replacement sponges are sold by size and pack count, but the deciding factor is the filter they slide onto. The two Castle Dawn Aquatics options in this catalog are built for different barrel designs: the XY-2831 is listed for double barrel and single barrel air-driven bio sponge filters, while the XY-280 is listed for single barrel air-driven bio sponge filters. Check which barrel style you run before comparing anything else.

Both products are described as universal replacements that fit any brand of aquarium sponge filter of similar size and design. That wording matters: the fit depends on matching the size and design, not on the brand name printed on your filter.

The Two Sponge Sizes Side by Side

  • Medium Filter Replacement Layered Sponges XY-2831 Pack of 10: Size 2831: 8 x 4.5cm (H*L), pack of 10 layered sponges. The height and length are the numbers to compare against your filter body; the pack of 10 suits keepers who want spares on hand.

    Medium Filter Replacement Layered Sponges XY-2831 Pack of 10

    Medium Filter Replacement Layered Sponges XY-2831 Pack of 10

  • Medium Filter Replacement Layered Sponges XY-280 Pack of 6: Size XY-280: 6.5 x 12cm (H*L), pack of 6 layered sponges. A different height-to-length ratio than the 2831, so measure your filter rather than assuming either will fit.

    Medium Filter Replacement Layered Sponges XY-280 Pack of 6

    Medium Filter Replacement Layered Sponges XY-280 Pack of 6

How to Size a Replacement Sponge

Work from the filter body outward. The catalog gives sponge dimensions in H*L format, so measure the same way on your own filter.

  1. Identify the barrel style: Single barrel or double barrel. The XY-2831 is listed for both; the XY-280 is listed for single barrel filters.
  2. Measure the filter body: Measure the height and length of the section the sponge covers, in centimeters, to compare directly with the listed sizes.
  3. Compare against the listed sizes: XY-2831 is 8 x 4.5cm (H*L); XY-280 is 6.5 x 12cm (H*L). If neither matches your measurement, the supplied information does not confirm a fit for your filter.
  4. Choose the pack count: The 2831 comes as a pack of 10; the XY-280 comes as a pack of 6. Pick based on how many spares you want, not on a cleaning schedule the catalog does not specify.

Which Sponge Fits Which Filter

  • XY-2831 (pack of 10): Listed for double barrel and single barrel air-driven bio sponge filters. 8 x 4.5cm (H*L). Made from a cotton blend.
  • XY-280 (pack of 6): Listed for single barrel air-driven bio sponge filters. 6.5 x 12cm (H*L). Made from 100% cotton.

What Both Sponges Have in Common

Both are layered replacement sponges made from ethically sourced cotton, and both carry a 1 year warranty with terms and conditions applying. Neither listing includes the filter itself, so these are spares for a filter you already own.

The material difference is worth noting: the XY-280 is listed as 100% cotton, while the XY-2831 is listed as a cotton blend. The catalog does not state how that difference affects lifespan or cleaning, so treat it as a specification rather than a performance claim.

Before You Order

The supplied records do not include preparation or operating instructions for either sponge, so follow the guidance that came with your filter for installation and maintenance. What the catalog does confirm is the size, the pack count, the barrel types each sponge is listed for, and that the filter is not included.

If your filter body does not match either listed size, the information here is not enough to confirm compatibility. Measure first, then decide.