The short answer: same serving count, different drink

Both refill bags give you 30 servings of MUD\WTR beverage powder, so the serving math is a wash. The real decision comes down to what you want in the cup: a smooth, energizing matcha drink or a convenient coffee alternative. The Matcha Refill Bag (30s) is built around premium matcha powder, while the Coffee Refill Bag (30s) is positioned as a coffee alternative. Neither refill comes with a new container—both are designed to top up your existing MUD\WTR container—so your choice should start with flavor and routine, not packaging.

What each refill actually contains

  • Matcha Refill Bag (30s): Contains 30 servings of premium matcha powder, designed as a refill for your existing container to reduce waste. If you already own a MUD\WTR container and want a matcha drink, this refill gives you a full 30-serving cycle without buying another tub.

    Matcha Refill Bag (30s)

    Matcha Refill Bag (30s)

  • Coffee Refill Bag (30s): Contains 30 individual servings of MUD\WTR beverage powder, designed as a refill option for your existing MUD\WTR container. The Coffee Refill Bag matches the Matcha Refill Bag on serving count, so you are not sacrificing quantity by choosing coffee flavor.

    Coffee Refill Bag (30s)

    Coffee Refill Bag (30s)

Packaging and storage differences that affect daily use

  • Matcha Refill Bag (30s): The catalog describes it as an eco-friendly refill that is easy to store and use for daily enjoyment. It is a refill bag, not a rigid container, so plan to transfer the powder into your existing MUD\WTR container or keep it sealed between uses. The supplied record does not specify whether the bag itself is resealable.
  • Coffee Refill Bag (30s): The Coffee Refill Bag is explicitly packaged in a resealable bag for freshness and easy storage. That resealable feature is a practical edge if you like to keep the bag in the pantry and scoop directly from it rather than decanting everything at once. The record does not state a shelf life after opening.

Price and value: what the catalog shows

At the listed catalog prices, the Matcha Refill Bag (30s) is USD 27.20 and the Coffee Refill Bag (30s) is USD 24.00. Both show a comparison price of USD 40.00, so the coffee refill is the lower-cost option per bag. Per serving, both give you 30 servings, so the coffee refill costs less per serving at those catalog prices. Prices can change, and the catalog does not explain the reason for the comparison price, so treat these as the numbers to check at checkout rather than a permanent ranking.

Which refill fits your routine?

  • Choose the Matcha Refill Bag (30s) if…: You want a matcha drink and already have a MUD\WTR container to refill. The catalog positions it for making a smooth, energizing drink, and the 30-serving bag supports a daily matcha habit without committing to a larger format. It is also the refill described as reducing waste through refill packaging.
  • Choose the Coffee Refill Bag (30s) if…: You want a coffee alternative and value a resealable bag for straightforward storage. The catalog describes it as a convenient, consistent coffee alternative with a no-fuss way to keep your favorite drink on hand. It is also the lower-priced of the two refills in the catalog.
  • Consider buying both if…: You like variety and already own at least one MUD\WTR container. Each bag gives 30 servings, so two bags give you 60 servings total across two drink styles. The supplied records do not state whether the same container is compatible with both powders, so confirm that before mixing and matching.

What the supplied information does not settle

The records for both refills do not include preparation instructions, allergen statements, caffeine content, or shelf-life details. That means you should not assume a specific mixing ratio, brewing temperature, or storage duration from this comparison. Check the packaging or the product page for those details before you buy. The Matcha Refill Bag record also does not confirm whether its bag is resealable, while the Coffee Refill Bag record does confirm a resealable bag. Neither record states whether the refill bags are compatible with every MUD\WTR container, so if you are unsure, verify container compatibility before ordering.