The Real Difference Is the Silhouette, Not the Fabric
Both trunks in this comparison use the same luxury modal blend: 88% modal and 12% elastane, with four-way stretch and high recovery. They share soft logo elastic, a contoured pouch, machine washability and the same everyday positioning from sleep to street. If you are choosing between them, fabric softness and breathability will not separate them. The decision comes down to fit, the fly, and how many sizes and colors you can actually get.
That narrows the question to two practical ones: do you want a closer modern fit or a roomier relaxed fit, and does a functional fly matter to your routine? The rest of this guide walks through those points and flags where the supplied product information leaves gaps.
Modern Fit vs Relaxed Fit at a Glance
The table below sticks to what the product records confirm. Where a detail is not listed, treat it as unconfirmed rather than assuming either trunk has or lacks it.
- Fit: Modern Fit Trunk: modern fit. Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly: relaxed fit. This is the clearest difference between the two.
- Fly: Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly: functional fly. The Modern Fit Trunk record does not list a fly, so its presence is not confirmed by the supplied information.
- Fabric: Both: 88% modal, 12% elastane, four-way stretch and high recovery, high breathability.
- Pack size: Both are sold as three-packs: the Relaxed Fit Trunk as three micro modal trunks, the Modern Fit Trunk as three micro modal briefs.
- Sizes listed: Modern Fit: Small, Medium, Large, Extra Large. Relaxed Fit: Medium and XX Large only, per the available variant evidence.
- Colors listed: Modern Fit: Black, Dark Navy, Titanium. Relaxed Fit: Black.
What the Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly Offers
-
Essential Modal Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly 3-Pack: Relaxed fit with a functional fly and contoured pouch. If you prefer a roomier cut and use a fly, this is the trunk that confirms both features in its record.
Essential Modal Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly 3-Pack
-
Essential Modal Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly 3-Pack: Three-pack of micro modal trunks in 88% modal and 12% elastane, with four-way stretch, high recovery and high breathability. The fabric matches the Modern Fit Trunk, so you are not trading softness or stretch for the relaxed silhouette.
-
Essential Modal Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly 3-Pack: Available variants listed: Medium / Black and XX Large / Black. The listed size and color range is narrow. If you wear Small, Large or Extra Large, or want navy or titanium, this trunk may not be available in your combination.
What the Modern Fit Trunk Offers
-
Essential Modal Modern Fit Trunk: Modern fit with a contoured pouch and soft logo elastic. A closer cut than the relaxed trunk, with the same pouch and waistband construction.
Essential Modal Modern Fit Trunk
-
Essential Modal Modern Fit Trunk: Three-pack of micro modal briefs in 88% modal and 12% elastane, with four-way stretch, high recovery and high breathability. Same fabric story as the Relaxed Fit Trunk, so fit rather than fabric should drive your choice.
-
Essential Modal Modern Fit Trunk: Available variants listed across Small, Medium, Large and Extra Large in Black, Dark Navy and Titanium. The broader listed size and color range makes this the easier trunk to match to your usual size and wardrobe.
How to Decide Between the Two
Choose the Relaxed Fit Trunk with Fly if a roomier cut is your priority and you want a confirmed functional fly. Check the listed variants first: the available evidence shows Medium and XX Large in Black, so confirm your size and color are offered before committing.
Choose the Modern Fit Trunk if you prefer a closer fit, do not specifically need a fly, or wear a size outside Medium and XX Large. Its listed range covers Small through Extra Large in three colors, which makes it the more flexible option on paper.
If you are unsure between the two silhouettes, the shared modal blend means you can judge them mainly on how much room you want through the seat and thigh. Neither record supplies a size chart or measurement guidance, so use the listed size labels as your starting point and treat exact fit as something to verify with the retailer.
Details Neither Record Confirms
A fair comparison should be clear about what the supplied information does not cover. These points are unconfirmed, not evidence of a missing feature.
- Care instructions: Both records state machine washable, but no washing temperature, drying method or other care steps are supplied. Follow the care label on the garment.
- Rise and inseam: No rise, leg length or measurement details are listed for either trunk, so you cannot compare them numerically from this information alone.
- Fly on the Modern Fit: The Modern Fit Trunk record does not mention a fly. Do not assume it has one or lacks one based on this comparison.
- Full size and color range: Variant evidence may be partial. The Relaxed Fit Trunk shows only Medium and XX Large in Black here, but the full catalog may list more.

