The real difference is in the backing, not just the artwork
The Mushrooms Dog Collar and the Tattoo Art Series Eagles Dog Collar both come from Cycle Dog and both are handmade in the USA, but the supplied listings describe different constructions. The Mushrooms collar is built around a waterproof, upcycled rubber backing that the listing says resists odors and bacteria growth. The Eagles collar is described as made with recycled materials and durable for daily wear, but the listing does not name a waterproof backing or an anti-bacterial treatment.
That gap matters more than the print itself if your dog swims, hikes in wet grass, or gets rained on. For a dog that mostly walks on dry sidewalks, the visual style may be the deciding factor. For a dog that gets wet regularly, the Mushrooms listing gives you more concrete evidence to work with.
Mushrooms vs Eagles at a glance
- Water and odor resistance: The Mushrooms listing explicitly describes a waterproof backing that resists odors and bacteria growth. The Eagles listing does not confirm a waterproof or anti-bacterial backing.
- Hardware: The Mushrooms collar lists a Latch-Lock metal buckle described as 4x stronger than plastic, a leash attachment that doubles as a bottle opener, and a separate ID spot for tags and lights. The Eagles listing does not confirm buckle type, a bottle opener, or a separate ID attachment.
- Style: Mushrooms uses a mushroom print on a no-stink, waterproof collar. Eagles uses a tattoo-art eagle design as part of the Tattoo Art Series.
- Sizing and fit: Both listings offer only a Standard variant in the supplied evidence. Neither listing provides neck measurements, width, or adjustment range, so you cannot confirm fit from the catalog alone.
What the Mushrooms listing confirms
-
Mushrooms Dog Collar: The Mushrooms Dog Collar has a waterproof, upcycled rubber backing that the listing says resists odors and bacteria growth. This is the clearest practical advantage in the comparison for dogs that swim, hike wet trails, or get caught in rain.
Mushrooms Dog Collar
-
Mushrooms Dog Collar: The leash attachment doubles as a bottle opener, and the collar includes a separate ID spot for tags and lights. These are concrete hardware features you can compare against the Eagles collar, which does not list them.
-
Mushrooms Dog Collar: The Latch-Lock metal buckle is described as sturdy, secure, and 4x stronger than plastic. If buckle strength is a priority, the Mushrooms listing gives you a specific claim to evaluate.
What the Eagles listing confirms
-
Tattoo Art Series-Eagles Dog Collar: The Tattoo Art Series Eagles Dog Collar is handmade in the USA using recycled materials and features a distinctive eagle tattoo art design. This collar competes on bold style and recycled construction rather than on waterproofing or hardware claims.
Tattoo Art Series-Eagles Dog Collar
-
Tattoo Art Series-Eagles Dog Collar: The listing describes durable construction suitable for daily wear. That supports everyday use, but it does not confirm water resistance, buckle type, or a separate ID attachment.
Where each collar makes more sense
Choose the Mushrooms Dog Collar if your dog regularly gets wet, if you want a leash attachment that doubles as a bottle opener, or if a separate ID spot for tags and lights matters to you. The waterproof backing and odor-resistant claim are the strongest evidence in either listing for messy, outdoor routines.
Choose the Tattoo Art Series Eagles Dog Collar if the eagle tattoo design is the main reason you are shopping and your dog's collar stays mostly dry. The listing supports daily wear and recycled materials, but it does not give you the same water, odor, or hardware detail. If you need those features, the Mushrooms collar is the better-documented option in the supplied information.
A practical way to decide before you order
- Check your dog's routine: If swimming, rain, or muddy trails are common, the Mushrooms collar's waterproof backing is the stronger fit based on the listings.
- Decide whether hardware matters: The Mushrooms collar lists a metal Latch-Lock buckle, a bottle-opener leash attachment, and a separate ID spot. The Eagles listing does not confirm these features.
- Measure your dog's neck: Both listings show only a Standard variant and do not provide neck measurements or adjustment range. Measure your dog's neck and compare it to the product page or contact the store before ordering.
- Pick the print you will actually enjoy: Once the practical features are settled, the mushroom print and the eagle tattoo art are both style choices. There is no evidence that one print is more durable than the other.
What neither listing tells you
The supplied records for both collars do not include neck measurements, collar width, adjustment range, or weight limits. They also do not include cleaning instructions beyond the Mushrooms collar's waterproof and odor-resistant backing description. If fit or care is critical for your dog, check the product page or ask the store directly rather than assuming a standard size will work. The absence of these details in the catalog is a limitation of the listing, not a confirmed product flaw.




