Two cotton muslin covers, two different care stories

Both covers here are made from 100% cotton muslin, so the real decision comes down to fit details, washing rules and how much print choice matters to you. The Little Unicorn Cotton Muslin Changing Pad Cover fits standard changing pads measuring 16" x 32" and comes in four prints. The Mushie Changing Pad Cover fits USA standard size changing pads at 32 x 16 inches, offers ten colorways and has two holes for safety belts.

Neither cover is a standard fabric cover in the sense of a woven cotton sheet. They are both muslin, which is why the comparison focuses on the practical differences you can verify from the product records rather than on broad claims about muslin versus other fabrics.

What each cover is made of and how it fits

  • Cotton Muslin Changing Pad Cover: 100% cotton muslin for softness, breathability, and comfort; fits standard changing pads (16" x 32") with elastic edges for a snug, secure fit. If your pad matches this size, the elastic edge is the main feature that keeps the cover in place during changes.

    Cotton Muslin Changing Pad Cover

    Cotton Muslin Changing Pad Cover

  • Changing Pad Cover: Made from 100% cotton, pre-washed, with a full elastic edge and two holes for safety belts; fits USA standard size changing pad: 32 x 16 inches. The safety-belt holes are a practical difference if your changing pad has straps you want to keep accessible.

    Changing Pad Cover

    Changing Pad Cover

Where the two covers actually differ

The shared material makes the fabric feel similar on paper. The meaningful differences are in the care instructions, the belt openings and the style range.

  • Washing rules: The Little Unicorn cover is described as machine washable for easy care. The Mushie cover specifies: do not wash at temperatures over 80F and do not tumble dry. If you prefer low-fuss laundry, that temperature and drying limit is the biggest practical tradeoff.
  • Safety belt access: The Mushie cover has two holes for safety belts. The supplied information for the Little Unicorn cover does not mention belt holes, so if your pad uses straps, check that detail before buying.
  • Print versus color range: The Little Unicorn cover comes in Fern, Porpoise, Prickle Pots and Taupe Cross prints. The Mushie cover comes in ten colors including Tradewinds, Pale Taupe, Natural Stripe, Fog, Roman Green, Rainbows, Cedar, White, Natural and Blush. Choose based on whether you want a pattern or a solid.
  • Price positioning: Catalog prices are USD 18.74 for the Little Unicorn cover (comparison price USD 24.99) and USD 16.32 for the Mushie cover (comparison price USD 24.00). Prices can change, so treat these as a starting point rather than a permanent ranking.

Which cover suits your changing setup?

If your priority is simple laundry, the Little Unicorn Cotton Muslin Changing Pad Cover is the clearer choice because it is described as machine washable without a stated temperature cap or tumble-dry ban. If your changing pad has safety belts and you want them accessible through the cover, the Mushie Changing Pad Cover is the one that lists belt holes. If you want the widest color matching for a neutral nursery, Mushie's ten colorways give you more options; if you prefer a nature-inspired print, Little Unicorn's Fern and Prickle Pots designs stand out.

One limitation to note: the supplied records do not state whether either cover is waterproof or whether they fit changing pads outside the listed sizes. Measure your pad before ordering, and use the care instructions exactly as given rather than assuming a general cotton wash setting.

Quick checks before you add to cart

  • Measure your changing pad: Both covers list a 16" x 32" fit. Confirm your pad matches before choosing.
  • Check for safety belts: Only the Mushie cover lists belt holes. If your pad has straps, this matters.
  • Match your laundry habits: The Mushie cover has an 80F wash limit and no tumble drying. The Little Unicorn cover is machine washable.
  • Pick your style: Four prints from Little Unicorn versus ten colors from Mushie.