Common Questions About Mystery Decks

What exactly is a Mystery Deck?

A Mystery Deck is a randomly selected deck of playing cards from Dan & Dave's collection. You pay a set price and receive one sealed deck (or a pack of five) from a curated list of possible decks. The selection is mixed and wrapped by hand so you won't know which deck you get until you open it.

What decks could be inside?

The possible decks include many past and current D&D releases, both in print and out of print. The full list ranges from Ace Fulton's Casino (most editions) and Antler (most colors) to Cardistry-Con (2019 and 2022), Case Study decks, Drifters (most colors), Fulton's Chinatown Anniversary Edition, Smoke & Mirrors Anniversary Edition (all colors and gilded), and many more. The complete list is provided by the store for transparency.

Can I find out what's inside before buying?

No—the surprise is the point. The decks are individually wrapped by hand and mixed for secrecy. The store includes a note: 'Not a fan of surprises? Highlight this area to reveal deck selection.' That hint is part of the product page, but the actual deck you receive remains a mystery until you open it.

Are Mystery Decks worth the price?

The catalog price is USD 39.60, with a comparison price of USD 60.00, suggesting a potential savings if you receive a deck that originally retailed higher. Since the possible decks include limited and out-of-print editions, some buyers find the value appealing. However, you might also receive a deck with a lower original price, so the value depends on which deck you get.

Can I return or exchange a Mystery Deck?

All Mystery Deck sales are final. Because the contents are random and the deck is sealed, returns and exchanges are not accepted. Be sure you're comfortable with the surprise element before purchasing.

How many decks can I order?

Two variant options are available: a Single Deck or a Pack of 5. The Pack of 5 gives you five individually sealed mystery decks, each from the same possible pool.

Key Facts About Mystery Decks

  • Mystery Decks: The Mystery Deck collection includes an assortment of D&D playing cards, both available and out of print. The full list of possibilities is provided for transparency. You know exactly which decks you might receive, so you can judge whether the surprise is worth the price based on the pool of options.

    Mystery Decks

    Mystery Decks