Two PEZ Refills, One Question

If you own a PEZ dispenser, you've likely faced this choice: Mystery Flavor PEZ or Assorted Fruit? Both come in a 6-pack, both are made in the USA, and both are labeled peanut, tree nut, and gluten free. But the experience of eating them is quite different. This comparison focuses on what you can expect from each, based on the available product information.

Flavor Experience

  • Mystery Flavor PEZ (color-free): Each wrapper contains a surprise fruit flavor. The candy tablets are color-free, so the mystery is purely about taste. The ingredients list includes natural & artificial flavors, sugar, corn syrup, adipic acid, and hydrogenated oils.
  • Assorted Fruit PEZ: Each 6-pack offers randomly assorted candy tablets within each wrapper. The flavors are fruit-based but not specified beyond that. The packaging notes the assortment is random, so you get a variety of fruit tastes across the pack.

What the Labels Tell Us

  • Mystery Flavor PEZ (color-free) - 6 Pack: Ingredients: sugar, corn syrup, adipic acid, hydrogenated palm kernel & palm oils, mono & diglycerides, natural & artificial flavors. The Mystery Flavor PEZ uses hydrogenated oils and natural & artificial flavors. If you prefer to avoid hydrogenated fats, this is a detail to note.

    Mystery Flavor PEZ (color-free) - 6 Pack

    Mystery Flavor PEZ (color-free) - 6 Pack

  • Assorted Fruit - 6 Pack: Peanut, Tree Nut & Gluten Free. Candy Made in USA. Both products share these allergen and origin claims. This is useful for those with common allergies or who prefer US-made candy.

    Assorted Fruit - 6 Pack

    Assorted Fruit - 6 Pack

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Mystery Flavor PEZ if you enjoy surprises and want a color-free candy option. The mystery is in the taste, not the appearance. Choose Assorted Fruit PEZ if you prefer a known fruit flavor experience with a random assortment inside each wrapper. Both are priced the same at $1.99 for a 6-pack, so your decision comes down to flavor preference and whether you want a color-free candy.