Quick Answer
Pick your usual size for a standard fit, but size up if you prefer a looser look or plan to layer. Since the design is random, focus on size first.
Why Size Matters More Than the Design
When you order a mystery shirt, the design is a surprise, but the fit should not be. The right size ensures you'll actually wear it, no matter which past design arrives.
Most apparel fits true to size, but fabric blends and cuts can vary. If you're between sizes, consider your usual preference: snug, standard, or relaxed.
Trade-Offs: Standard vs. Relaxed Fit
Choosing your usual size gives a familiar, standard fit. Sizing up offers more room, which works well for layering or if you prefer a looser silhouette.
Sizing down is risky because you can't exchange the design, and a too-tight shirt is less likely to get worn. When in doubt, choose the larger size.
How to Choose Your Mystery Shirt Size
- Measure a shirt you already own: Lay a well-fitting shirt flat and measure from armpit to armpit and from the top of the collar to the hem. Compare these numbers to the size chart on the product page. Use the measurements, not just the letter size, because sizing can vary between brands.
- Decide on your preferred fit: If you like a standard, true-to-size fit, order your usual size. If you prefer a looser or relaxed fit, or you plan to layer, size up. Remember that you cannot choose the design, so prioritize the fit you'll feel most comfortable in.
- Check the size chart before ordering: Review the size chart provided for the Mystery Shirt. If you are between sizes, choose the larger size for a safer fit. Sizing up is safer than sizing down, especially when returns or exchanges are limited.
Product Facts
-
Mystery Shirt: The Mystery Shirt is selected at random from a handful of past designs, and you choose only your size. Because the design is random, your size choice is the only way to influence the fit, so getting it right matters.
Mystery Shirt


