Two ways to buy the same Cocoon style
The Natural Cocoon+ and the 2 Are Better Than 1 set both give you the Cocoon shawl, but they answer different questions. One is a single shawl in a natural color; the other is a set of two Cocoons (Natural and Olive) sold together. The right choice depends on how you plan to use your cover, how often you wash it, and whether you want a backup or a second color.
Both options share the same core design: a breathable knit nursing cover that doubles as a scarf, stroller cover, and blanket. The differences come down to quantity, color, and what each listing emphasizes about care and fit.
What you get with each option
-
Natural Cocoon+: Natural Cocoon+ is a single shawl in Natural, made from 65% polyester and 35% rayon, and fits mamas up to 6'5" and dress size 24. This is the straightforward single-shawl purchase if you want one neutral cover that matches most outfits.
Natural Cocoon+
-
2 Are Better Than 1 - Natural & Olive Cocoon+: 2 Are Better Than 1 includes two Cocoons in Natural and Olive, each made from 65% polyester and 35% regenerative rayon, and fits mamas up to 6'5" and size 24. You get two colors and a spare, which can be useful if one is in the wash or you want to coordinate with different looks.
2 Are Better Than 1 - Natural & Olive Cocoon+
Fabric and coverage: what changes between the two
Both shawls use a breathable knit blend, but the set uses regenerative rayon while the single uses standard rayon. The set also notes that the Cocoon+ has more fabric for more coverage, though the single listing does not specify a coverage difference. If coverage is your top priority, the set's description explicitly calls out extra fabric.
- Fabric composition: Natural Cocoon+: 65% polyester, 35% rayon. 2 Are Better Than 1: 65% polyester, 35% regenerative rayon. Both are lightweight and breathable according to the listings.
- Coverage: The set listing says the Cocoon+ has more fabric for more coverage. The single listing does not make that claim, so treat extra coverage as a set-specific feature unless you confirm otherwise.
- Fit range: Both fit up to 6'5" and size 24, so sizing is not a differentiator.
Care instructions: nearly identical, with one small difference
The Natural Cocoon+ listing gives clear care steps: machine wash cold on gentle cycle, then tumble dry low or lay flat to dry. It also recommends washing and drying in the provided laundry bag for best results. The 2 Are Better Than 1 listing does not include its own care steps, but it does mention that the yarn was chosen to be easy to care for and durable. Since the set contains the same style of Cocoon, it is reasonable to follow the same care routine, but the set listing itself does not spell it out. If you want written care instructions specific to your purchase, the single listing is more explicit.
Care and durability details from the listings
- Natural Cocoon+: Machine wash cold, gentle cycle; tumble dry low or lay flat to dry; use the provided laundry bag for best results. These are the only explicit care steps in the two listings, so they are the safest guide for either purchase.
- 2 Are Better Than 1 - Natural & Olive Cocoon+: The yarn was selected to be breathable, lightweight, easy to care for, and durable enough to last a lifetime. This supports the set's long-term value claim, though it is a general statement rather than a specific care instruction.
Value: one shawl or two?
The set costs more upfront, but it gives you two shawls in different colors. If you plan to use your Cocoon daily, having a second one means you are never without a cover while one is in the wash. The set listing also notes that 62% of mamas who bought one Cocoon regret not buying a second, which suggests that repeat buyers often want a backup. The single shawl is the lower-cost entry point if you are unsure how much you will use a nursing cover or if you prefer to start with one neutral color.
Which should you choose?
- Choose Natural Cocoon+ if...: You want one versatile, neutral shawl at a lower upfront cost, and you prefer explicit care instructions in the listing.
- Choose 2 Are Better Than 1 if...: You want two colors (Natural and Olive), extra coverage from more fabric, and a spare for laundry days or travel.
- Consider your washing routine: If you wash frequently or want to keep one cover clean for outings, the two-shawl set reduces the chance of being caught without a cover.
What the listings do not tell you
Neither listing provides a specific care routine for the set beyond the general yarn description, so if you buy the set, rely on the single listing's care steps as a reasonable guide. The set's claim of "more fabric" is not quantified, so if you need precise coverage measurements, ask the store before ordering. Also, neither listing confirms whether the shawls are suitable for newborns or safe-sleep use; those are not stated, so do not assume they are.

